Skip to content
AP MacroeconomicsBasic Economic Concepts
Explore another subject
AP · macroeconomicsONE COMPLETE FREE SECTION

Scarcity

AP Macroeconomics · Basic Economic Concepts

Your course level

Everyone in this class reads the same notes.

The sample stays complete. Sign up when you’re ready to continue the unit.

0 highlighted

Scarcity

Economics starts with one plain fact about the world: people want more than there is.

A family in Ohio would like a bigger home, a newer car, a vacation and money set aside for college, but it has one paycheck.

A city council in Texas would like more police officers, more parks and lower property taxes, but it has one budget.

The federal government faces the same problem on a vastly larger scale every time Congress passes a budget.

In every case the wants are bigger than the means of satisfying them, so somebody has to choose.

That is the whole idea of this first topic.

You need to know that "Individuals and societies are forced to make choices because most resources are scarce."

Read that sentence slowly, because each part matters.

Individuals and societies means it applies at every level, from one student deciding how to spend a Saturday to a whole country deciding what to produce.

Forced to make choices means choosing is not optional: you cannot have everything, so you must give something up.

Most resources are scarce means the things used to produce goods and services are limited compared with what people want from them.

What "scarce" means to an economist

In everyday speech "scarce" means rare.

In economics a resource is scarce when there is not enough of it to satisfy everyone's wants for it at a price of zero.

Water is not rare in the United States, yet it is scarce: cities, farms and factories all want more than the rivers and aquifers supply.

In August 2021 the US Bureau of Reclamation declared the first-ever shortage on the Colorado River for 2022, which cut Arizona's share by 512,000 acre-feet, about 18% of its yearly allocation.

Arizona farmers, cities and the rest of the economy then had to decide who would do without.

That is scarcity at work.

The photograph below shows what a long drought looks like at a reservoir on a desert river system: the pale band on the rock marks where the water used to reach, and every user downstream has to share what is left.

Photograph of a desert reservoir at very low water, with a pale band on the canyon walls marking how high the water once stood and dry exposed ground above the shrunken waterline.
Photograph of a desert reservoir at very low water, with a pale band on the canyon walls marking how high the water once stood and dry exposed ground above the shrunken waterline.

Scarcity is permanent.

A country that grows richer can produce more, but people's wants grow too (better health care, faster internet, more travel), and time never grows: every person, rich or poor, has 24 hours a day.

So scarcity never disappears; what changes is how much a society can produce from what it has.

Scarcity is also different from a shortage.

A shortage is a market situation in which, at the current price, buyers want to buy more than sellers want to sell.

It is temporary, because the price can rise until the gap closes (you meet this properly in the market equilibrium sections of this unit).

Scarcity does not go away when prices change.

A good can be scarce with no shortage at all: gasoline is scarce, but a gas station that charges the market price rarely runs out.

The Colorado River case uses the word "shortage" as a legal term for low water levels; an economist would describe the underlying problem as scarcity.

Economic resources: the four factors of production

The resources that produce goods (things you can touch, such as cars and bread) and services (actions done for you, such as a haircut or a doctor's visit) are called economic resources or factors of production.

Economists sort them into four groups, and each earns its own kind of income:

Factor

What it is

US example

Income it earns

Land

Natural resources: anything that comes from nature, such as soil, minerals, forests, water and oil

Farmland in Iowa; oil under the Permian Basin in Texas

Rent

Labor

Human effort, physical and mental, used in production

A nurse's shift in a Chicago hospital

Wages

Capital

Goods made by people and used to produce other goods and services: tools, machines, buildings, equipment

A delivery truck; a factory in Michigan; a laptop used for work

Interest

Entrepreneurship

The ability to combine the other three, take risks, organize a business and innovate

A founder who opens a new restaurant and decides its menu

Profit

Two points about capital catch many students.

First, in economics capital means physical capital, the tools and machines.

Money is not capital: money is financial capital, which can be used to buy physical capital, but a pile of dollars produces nothing by itself.

Second, the skills and knowledge that workers gain from education and training are called human capital.

Human capital makes labor more productive.

You use both ideas again: a larger stock of physical capital and more human capital are what shift the production possibilities curve outward later in this unit, and they are the main sources of long-run economic growth in Unit 5.

Scarcity, choice and opportunity cost

Because resources are scarce, every use of a resource has a cost: the value of what that resource could have produced instead.

If a hospital in Denver uses a floor of its building for a new cancer center, that floor cannot also be used for more emergency beds.

If you spend Saturday afternoon studying, you cannot also spend it working a paid shift.

The opportunity cost of a choice is the value of the next best alternative you give up.

Notice "next best": it is the single best option you did not choose, not a list of everything you could have done.

The next topic measures opportunity cost with numbers.

Every society answers three basic questions because of scarcity: what to produce (more hospitals or more highways?), how to produce it (with more workers or more machines?)

and for whom (who gets the output?).

In the United States most of these answers come from markets, with buyers and sellers responding to prices, and some come from government decisions such as the federal budget.

Microeconomics and macroeconomics

Microeconomics studies the choices of individual households, firms and markets: why the price of eggs rose, how a firm decides how many workers to hire.

Macroeconomics, the subject of this course, studies the economy as a whole: total output (gross domestic product), the overall price level and inflation, the unemployment rate, economic growth and the policies that affect them.

Scarcity runs through both.

In macroeconomics it shows up as a limit on the total output an economy can produce when all its resources are in use, which is the full-employment output you meet on the production possibilities curve in the next topic and again as long-run aggregate supply in Unit 3.

How the points work
  • The multiple-choice section has 60 questions with five options, (A) to (E); each is 1 point and a wrong answer costs nothing, so answer every one.
  • In the free-response questions every scoring row is worth exactly 1 point. There are no levels and no half points: a row is earned or not.
  • "Draw a correctly labeled graph ... and show ..." is 2 points: the first for the labeled graph (both axes, every curve, the starting position or equilibrium marked on the axes), the second for the situation or the change the question asks for. A later "On your graph in Part A, show ..." is 1 point.
  • "Calculate ... Show your work." is 1 point, earned only with the right value and the line of work that produces it. A four-function calculator is allowed on both sections.
  • "... ? Explain." is 1 point for the direction and the reason together; the right direction with no reason, or with the wrong reason, earns nothing.
  • "Identify" asks for one precise answer, with no explanation needed; for a policy action that means one specific instrument ("increase government spending", "buy bonds"), never only a direction such as "expansionary policy".
  • Every monetary-policy question states whether the banking system has ample or limited reserves, and the tool you name must fit that regime (you learn both in Unit 4).
  • Constraint words in a question are scored: "based solely on", "in the short run" against "in the long run", "with the same quantity of resources". Answer inside them; "Assume that ..." and "Assume instead ..." set up the situation you must answer within.
  • Do not count on credit for a later part that builds correctly on a wrong earlier answer: check each value before you carry it forward.
  • No point values are printed on the exam questions; the check questions here print only the total.
Key terms
  • Scarcity and choice: Individuals and societies are forced to make choices because most resources are scarce.
  • Scarce resource: a resource whose available quantity is too small to satisfy all the wants for it at a price of zero.
  • Economic resources (factors of production): land, labor, capital and entrepreneurship, the inputs used to produce goods and services.
  • Capital: goods made by people that are used to produce other goods and services, such as machines, tools and buildings; money is not capital.
  • Human capital: the knowledge and skills workers gain through education, training and experience.
  • Opportunity cost: the value of the next best alternative given up when a choice is made.
Worked example 1: sorting a business's resources into the four factors

A bakery opens in Columbus, Ohio.

Classify each item as land, labor, capital, entrepreneurship, human capital, or none of the factors.

Item

Factor

Why

The plot of ground the bakery stands on

Land

It is a natural resource, earning rent

The bakers' hours at work

Labor

Human effort used in production, earning wages

The ovens, mixers and delivery van

Capital

Made by people, used to make other goods

The owner who risked her savings, chose the menu and hired the staff

Entrepreneurship

Organizing the other factors and bearing the risk, earning profit

The head baker's pastry training

Human capital

Skill gained through training, which makes her labor more productive

A $50,000 bank loan

None (financial capital)

Money buys capital but produces nothing itself

Answer: land, labor, capital, entrepreneurship, human capital, and the loan is financial capital, not a factor of production.

What to notice: the loan is the row most students get wrong.

The ovens the loan pays for are capital; the loan is not.

Worked example 2: an Explain answer on why scarcity never disappears

The country of Lindora discovers a large new deposit of natural gas, doubling the energy it can produce.

Will scarcity disappear in Lindora?

Explain.

Answer as a student would write it: "No. The new gas raises the quantity of one resource, but people's wants still exceed what Lindora can produce, and the labor and capital used to extract the gas can no longer be used to make other things, so Lindora still has to choose."

Point 1. States that scarcity will not disappear and explains that wants remain greater than the resources available (or that using resources for one purpose still means giving up another).

Does not earn: "No, because resources are scarce."

That repeats the claim without the reason, so it scores 0.

Does not earn: "Yes, because Lindora now has plenty of energy."

Having more of one resource does not end the gap between unlimited wants and limited resources.

Worked example 3: naming the opportunity cost of a choice

The town council of Ridgeway, Kansas, owns one empty lot downtown.

Its options, in its own order of preference, are a public park, a parking garage and a farmers' market building.

It builds the park.

What is the opportunity cost of the park?

Explain.

Answer as a student would write it: "The opportunity cost is the parking garage, because it is the next best use of the same lot, and the town can build only one thing there."

Point 1. Identifies the single next best alternative given up and explains that the lot can be used for only one project.

Does not earn: "the parking garage and the farmers' market building".

Listing every alternative is a common slip; you can give up only one next best use, because you could never have done both of the others at once with one lot.

Does not earn: "the money spent on the park".

The money cost is part of the story, but the question asks what use of the scarce resource was given up.

Exam tip

When a question asks for the opportunity cost of a choice, name one thing: the next best alternative given up, stated in units of what was given up (hours of work, a parking garage, tons of wheat).

An answer that lists several alternatives, or names the option that was chosen, does not earn the point.

Common mistakes
  • "Money is capital." It is tempting because in business news "capital" often means money. In economics capital is the physical tools and machines; money is financial capital that buys them.
  • "Scarcity and shortage are the same thing." Both suggest "not enough", so the mix-up is natural. Scarcity is permanent and affects every resource; a shortage is a temporary market gap at a price below equilibrium, which a price rise removes.
  • "Rich countries do not face scarcity." They produce more, so it feels as if their problem is solved. But wants grow with income and time is fixed, so every country still chooses.
  • "Opportunity cost is everything you gave up." Lists feel thorough. The opportunity cost is only the next best alternative.

Check your understanding

1. Which of the following is an example of capital as a factor of production? (A) Shares of stock in a technology company (B) A forklift used in a warehouse in Memphis (C) The balance in a firm's checking account (D) A forest owned by a lumber company (E) The time a software engineer spends writing code

Total [1]

2. Which of the following statements about scarcity is correct? (A) Scarcity exists only in countries with low incomes. (B) Scarcity disappears when a market reaches equilibrium. (C) Scarcity means a good is temporarily out of stock in stores. (D) Scarcity exists because wants exceed the resources available to satisfy them. (E) Scarcity applies to natural resources but not to time.

Total [1]

3. Which of the following questions would be studied in macroeconomics? (A) Why did the price of a used pickup truck in Arizona rise last year? (B) How many workers should a restaurant hire for its weekend shifts? (C) Why did the national unemployment rate rise during a recession? (D) How does a farmer decide whether to plant corn or soybeans? (E) Why do concert tickets for one band sell out quickly?

Total [1]

4. Tomas has four free hours on Saturday. He can work a paid shift at a grocery store, study for a calculus test, or help at an animal shelter. He ranks studying first, working second and helping at the shelter third, and he chooses to study.

Part A

Identify the opportunity cost of Tomas's choice.

Part B

Assume that Tomas still ranks working second and helping at the shelter third.

The grocery store raises its hourly wage.

Will the opportunity cost of studying increase, decrease, or remain the same?

Explain.

Total [2]

5. A government official says, "Our country has become so wealthy that we no longer need to think about tradeoffs." Is the official correct? Explain.

Total [1]

6. A powerful hurricane destroys many factories and warehouses along the Gulf Coast. Will the scarcity of capital in the United States increase, decrease, or remain the same? Explain.

Total [1]

Answers

1. (B). A forklift is a tool made by people and used to produce a service (moving goods), so it is capital. (A) and (C) are financial assets, money claims that can buy capital but produce nothing themselves; they are tempting because business language calls them "capital". (D) is land, a natural resource. (E) is labor.

2. (D). Scarcity is the gap between wants and the resources to meet them. (A) is wrong because every economy faces scarcity. (B) confuses scarcity with a shortage: equilibrium removes a shortage, not scarcity. (C) describes a shortage. (E) is wrong because time is the clearest example of a scarce resource.

3. (C). The national unemployment rate describes the whole economy. (A), (B), (D) and (E) each concern one market, firm or producer, which is microeconomics; (A) and (E) are tempting because prices appear in macroeconomics too, but a single good's price is a micro question.

4. Answers:

  • Point 1 (Part A): Identifies the next best alternative given up, the paid shift at the grocery store (the wages he would have earned). Does not earn: "working and helping at the shelter" (only the next best alternative counts); "studying" (that is the choice, not what was given up).
  • Point 2 (Part B): States that the opportunity cost will increase and explains that the next best alternative, working, is still second, and it now pays more, so Tomas gives up more income by studying. The constraint "still ranks working second" is what fixes the answer: if a student argues that the shelter becomes the next best option, the question has ruled that out, and the answer scores 0. Does not earn: "increase" with no reason.

5. Point 1: The official is not correct, because even a wealthy country's wants exceed its resources (and time is fixed), so using resources for one purpose still means giving up another; tradeoffs remain. Does not earn: "No, because of scarcity" with no link to wants exceeding resources.

6. Point 1: Scarcity of capital will increase, because the hurricane reduces the quantity of capital available while the wants it serves (production of goods and services) are unchanged, so the gap between wants and available capital widens. Does not earn: "increase, because there is a shortage" (a shortage is a market gap at a price, not a fall in the amount of a resource).

Ready for the next section?

Create a free account to read the rest of this free unit, save highlights, track your confidence and plan your revision.

Your next step

Put this topic into practice.

These tools belong to this free unit. Create an account to open them and save your progress.

Free-response practice · Sign up to open

AP Macroeconomics Unit 1: Basic Economic Concepts. Free-response practice (Section II)

3 questions · Section II

Attempt the questions, check the scoring guidelines and record your own points.

Create free account to open this practice →
Multiple-choice practice · Sign up to open

AP Macroeconomics Unit 1: Basic Economic Concepts. Multiple-choice practice (Section I)

20 questions · Section I

Check your understanding and get explanations after you submit.

Create free account to try this quiz →

Other units and paper downloads depend on your plan.

Already have an account? Sign in →

Give your revision a routine.

Build a timetable, tick off daily tasks, catch up on missed work and opt in to weekly email reviews. Connect with your teacher when you want to share your progress.