Skip to content
AP MicroeconomicsBasic Economic Concepts
Explore another subject
AP · microeconomicsONE COMPLETE FREE SECTION

Scarcity

AP Microeconomics · Basic Economic Concepts

Your course level

Everyone in this class reads the same notes.

The sample stays complete. Sign up when you’re ready to continue the unit.

0 highlighted

Scarcity

Every week you make choices you would rather not have to make in quite the same way: an hour on homework or an hour at a part-time job, a concert ticket or new running shoes.

The reason you cannot have everything is the starting point of all of economics.

This section explains scarcity, the resources that are scarce, and the unusual resources that are not.

Wants, resources and scarcity

Economists split the world into two lists.

On one list are wants and needs: food, housing, health care, transportation, entertainment, a cleaner river, a faster phone.

That list never ends, because once one want is met a new one appears.

On the other list are resources, the things used to produce goods and services.

That list is limited at any moment: there is only so much farmland in Iowa, only so many trained nurses in Texas, only so many hours in your day.

You need to know that "Economic trade-offs arise from the lack of sufficient resources (scarcity) to meet society’s wants and needs."

Read that sentence as a chain of cause and effect:

  • Wants and needs are larger than what the available resources can produce.
  • So resources are scarce: there are not enough of them to give everyone everything they want.
  • So every use of a resource means giving up another use of it. That is a trade-off.

Scarcity is not the same as being rare or expensive, and it is not the same as poverty.

A billionaire still faces scarcity, because she has only 24 hours a day and cannot spend the same hour at a board meeting and at her daughter's softball game.

A resource is scarce whenever using it for one purpose means it cannot be used for another.

Scarcity is also not a shortage.

A shortage is a market situation, covered in Unit 2, where the quantity demanded is greater than the quantity supplied at the current price.

A shortage can be removed when the price rises.

Scarcity cannot be removed by any price: it is the permanent gap between wants and resources.

The factors of production

Resources used to produce goods and services are called factors of production.

The course names three in its wording, "land, labor, and capital", and most textbooks add a fourth:

Factor

What it includes

A US example

Land

Every natural resource: soil, water, minerals, forests, oil, wind

Groundwater pumped to irrigate almond orchards in the Central Valley of California

Labor

The physical and mental effort of people who work

Nurses in a Houston hospital

Capital

Goods made to produce other goods: machines, tools, buildings, equipment

A combine harvester on a Kansas farm; a server farm in Virginia

Entrepreneurship

The ability to combine the other factors and take the risk of starting a business

A founder who opens a bakery in Detroit

Two traps are worth fixing now.

First, in economics "capital" means physical capital (machines and buildings), not money.

Money lets you buy capital, but a bank balance does not produce anything by itself.

Second, the same item can be a factor or a final good depending on its use: a laptop bought by a family to stream movies is a consumer good; the same laptop bought by an accounting firm to prepare tax returns is capital.

You need to know that "Most factors of production (such as land, labor, and capital) are scarce, but some factors of production (such as established knowledge) may not be scarce due to their non-rival nature."

Why established knowledge may not be scarce

A good is rival when one person's use of it reduces the amount left for others.

A gallon of irrigation water used on one California field cannot also be used on the next field.

A nurse who spends an hour with one patient cannot spend that same hour with another.

Most factors of production are rival, which is why they are scarce.

Established knowledge is different.

Once a production method, a formula or a design is known, one firm using it does not use it up for anyone else.

When a bakery in Detroit uses the method for making sourdough bread, a bakery in San Francisco can use the same method at the same time, and the method is just as good for both.

Another example is open-source software such as the Linux operating system, first released in 1991, whose code any firm may copy and use without reducing what is available to others.

Knowledge like this is non-rival, so using more of it in one place does not mean less of it elsewhere.

That is why the course says it "may not be scarce".

Two cautions keep this precise.

First, creating new knowledge does use scarce resources: research needs scientists' time (labor) and laboratories (capital).

It is the knowledge that already exists that is non-rival.

Second, the law can limit who may use some knowledge (a patent, for example), but a patent makes knowledge excludable, not rival.

You will meet "rival" and "excludable" again in Unit 6, where they sort goods into private goods, public goods and others.

Scarcity in a real US market: California water in the 2015 drought

Much of California's water comes from winter rain and mountain snow, and the amount changes a great deal from year to year.

In a drought, farms, cities, households and the fish in the state's rivers all want more water than there is.

The photograph below shows what that trade-off looks like on a farm in the Central Valley: with too little water for every field, a farmer waters some fields and leaves others unplanted.

A bright green irrigated field beside a bare, unplanted field of dry cracked soil on a Central Valley farm in a drought, with an empty irrigation ditch between them
A bright green irrigated field beside a bare, unplanted field of dry cracked soil on a Central Valley farm in a drought, with an empty irrigation ditch between them

In April 2015, after several dry years and a record-low mountain snowpack, California's governor ordered the state's first-ever mandatory statewide cut in urban water use: cities and towns had to use 25 percent less drinking water than they had used in 2013.

Lawns went brown and car washes and showers got shorter, because every gallon used in a city was a gallon that could not stay in a reservoir for next year, flow down a river for salmon, or irrigate a farm.

Many farmers received far less water than usual and left fields unplanted.

That is scarcity producing a trade-off, exactly as the definition says.

Notice how the chain runs in the case: limited water (scarce land, in the economist's sense), more wants than the water can meet, so using water for one purpose means giving up another.

How this links to the rest of the course

  • Every trade-off has a cost: the value of the next best alternative given up. That is opportunity cost, which the cost-benefit section of this unit makes precise and which turns into implicit cost and economic profit in Unit 3.
  • Scarcity forces every society to decide what to produce, how, and for whom (the next section).
  • The production possibilities curve (later in this unit) draws scarcity: the curve is the boundary set by limited resources.
  • Non-rival knowledge returns in Unit 6, where public goods are non-rival and non-excludable.

How scarcity is examined

On the AP Microeconomics exam, multiple-choice questions on scarcity can ask you to identify the reason choices must be made, the meaning of scarce resources, and which factor of production an example shows.

In the free-response questions it sits behind every trade-off, opportunity cost and production possibilities curve.

An Explain answer about scarcity always needs both halves of the definition: resources are limited and wants are unlimited (or greater than what resources can produce), so choices or trade-offs must be made.

How the points work
  • Every scored element on the free-response questions is worth exactly 1 point: no levels, no half points, no partial credit. The long free-response question (Question 1) totals 10 points; each short free-response question (Questions 2 and 3) totals 5.
  • Identify, or a question with no "Explain": give the answer alone, in the question's own words. Extra explanation is not needed and can contradict you.
  • Explain: the assertion and the reason together earn the one point. A correct assertion with no reason, or with the wrong reason, earns nothing.
  • Explain using numbers (or marginal analysis, or labeling from the graph): quote the specific values from the table, graph or matrix and compare every pair the claim needs.
  • Calculate: the correct value with its work (the relationship, the numbers substituted, each step). A bare number earns nothing, and "Show your work." is always printed.
  • Draw a correctly labeled graph ... and show each of the following, or On your graph, show: each element is a separate point, and each needs its labels.
  • Graph rules: label both axes and every curve; draw curves solid and dashed guide lines from each point to both axes, with the label on the axis; use the question's labels exactly; show a shift as a new labeled curve with an arrow; shade an area completely.
  • Give one answer only. Two answers ("it increases or stays the same") lose the point.
  • Use the question's option words exactly ("increase, decrease, or remain the same").
  • A later part is credited only for the correct value: a wrong earlier answer is never carried forward.
  • The multiple-choice section has 60 questions with five options, (A) to (E), and no penalty for a wrong answer, so answer every question. A four-function calculator is allowed on both sections.
Key terms
  • Scarcity: Economic trade-offs arise from the lack of sufficient resources (scarcity) to meet society’s wants and needs.
  • Factors of production: Most factors of production (such as land, labor, and capital) are scarce, but some factors of production (such as established knowledge) may not be scarce due to their non-rival nature.
  • Trade-off: giving up some of one thing to get more of another, because the resources cannot do both.
  • Non-rival: one person's use does not reduce the amount available to others.
  • Capital (physical capital): goods made by people that are used to produce other goods and services, such as machines, tools and buildings.
Worked example 1: classifying factors of production

A craft brewery in Asheville, North Carolina, uses each of the following.

Classify each as land, labor, capital or established knowledge, and say whether it is scarce.

Item

Factor

Scarce?

Water from the French Broad River

Land (a natural resource)

Yes: water used in brewing cannot also be used by a farm downstream

The brewers' working hours

Labor

Yes: an hour spent brewing cannot be spent bottling

Stainless-steel brewing tanks

Capital

Yes: a tank full of one beer cannot hold another at the same time

The well-known method of fermenting beer with yeast

Established knowledge

No: the brewery's use of the method does not reduce anyone else's use of it, because it is non-rival

The step that decides the last row is the question "does one user's use leave less for others?"

For water, hours and tanks the answer is yes, so they are scarce.

For the method the answer is no.

Worked example 2: explaining why a society must make choices

Explain why a society must make choices about which goods and services to produce.

Full-point answer: Because the resources available to produce goods and services are limited while people's wants and needs are unlimited, resources are scarce, so using resources to produce one good means they cannot be used to produce another, and society must choose among the alternatives.

Point 1. Accept: wants exceed the resources available to satisfy them (scarcity), so every use of a resource involves a trade-off.

Does not earn: "because goods cost money" (prices are a result of scarcity, not its cause); "because some people are poor" (scarcity applies to rich and poor alike).

Weaker answer: "Because resources are scarce."

This scores 0 on an Explain: it gives the assertion's key word but not the reason, since it never says why scarcity forces a choice (unlimited wants against limited resources, so using a resource one way rules out another use).

Worked example 3: explaining why established knowledge may not be scarce

A software company in Austin, Texas, builds its products on a programming method that has been published for decades.

Explain why this method may not be a scarce factor of production for the company.

Full-point answer: The method is established knowledge, which is non-rival: the company's use of it does not reduce the amount available to any other firm, so many firms can use it at the same time without anyone giving up its use, and it does not force a trade-off the way scarce factors do.

Point 1. Accept: knowledge is not used up when it is used, so one firm's use leaves just as much for others.

Does not earn: "it is free" (price is not the test; a free good can still be rival); "it is not a physical object" (true, but it does not say why there is no trade-off).

Weaker answer: "Knowledge is unlimited."

This scores 0: it asserts the conclusion without the non-rival reason, the link the answer needs.

Exam tip

When an Explain part asks why choices or trade-offs must be made, write both sides of scarcity in one sentence: limited resources and unlimited wants, so using a resource for one thing means giving up another.

"Because of scarcity" names the idea but explains nothing, and it scores 0.

Common mistakes
  • Treating scarcity as a shortage. A shortage is quantity demanded greater than quantity supplied at a price below equilibrium, and a higher price removes it; scarcity never goes away. The mix-up is tempting because both words suggest "not enough".
  • Calling money "capital". In economics capital means physical capital such as machines and buildings; money only buys them. Everyday speech ("raising capital") makes this easy to get wrong.
  • Saying rich people or rich countries do not face scarcity. Everyone has limited resources, including time, so everyone faces trade-offs. It feels true because rich people face fewer hard choices about necessities.
  • Saying knowledge is not scarce because it is free or because it is not physical. The reason in the course is that existing knowledge is non-rival: one user's use does not leave less for others.
  • Saying all knowledge is free to produce. Creating new knowledge uses scarce scientists' time and laboratories; only knowledge that already exists is non-rival.

Check your understanding

1. Which of the following best explains why every society faces trade-offs? (A) Prices of goods and services rise over time. (B) Some people have higher incomes than others. (C) Resources are insufficient to produce everything that people want. (D) Governments limit the quantity of goods that firms can produce. (E) Quantity demanded is greater than quantity supplied in every market. Total [1]

2. A bakery in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, uses an oven, the labor of three bakers, flour, and a well-known recipe for rye bread. Which of the following correctly classifies the oven and the recipe? (A) The oven is capital, and the recipe is a scarce factor of production. (B) The oven is capital, and the recipe is non-rival established knowledge. (C) The oven is land, and the recipe is non-rival established knowledge. (D) The oven is labor, and the recipe is a scarce factor of production. (E) The oven is money capital, and the recipe is land. Total [1]

3. Which of the following is an example of a scarce factor of production? (A) The rule for adding fractions, used by every accounting firm in Ohio (B) A published formula that any chemical company may use (C) The design of the wheel, used by every bicycle maker (D) The working hours of the electricians employed by a builder in Denver (E) A well-known method for rotating crops, used by farms across Iowa Total [1]

4. A city council in Sacramento, California, has a fixed budget and a fixed number of city workers. It can use them to repair roads or to extend library hours. Part A Will extending library hours involve a trade-off for the city? Explain. Part B Identify the factor of production that the city workers represent. Total [2]

5. Two engineering firms in Pittsburgh both use the same published method for calculating the load a steel beam can carry. Will one firm's use of the method reduce the amount of the method available to the other firm? Explain. Total [1]

6. A student says, "My family has plenty of money, so scarcity does not apply to us." Is the student correct? Explain. Total [1]

7. Which of the following pairs correctly matches a situation with the economic idea it shows? (A) A shortage of concert tickets at a price below equilibrium: scarcity that can never be removed (B) A farmer who uses an acre for corn and so cannot use it for soybeans: a trade-off (C) A firm that buys a new forklift: an increase in land (D) Two firms using the same well-known design: a rival use of a resource (E) A worker who learns a new skill: a decrease in labor Total [1]

Answers

1. (C). Trade-offs arise because resources are not enough to meet all wants, which is scarcity. (A) is tempting because rising prices feel like scarcity, but price changes are not the reason trade-offs exist. (B) describes inequality; a society with equal incomes still faces trade-offs. (D) confuses scarcity with a government limit. (E) describes a shortage, a market situation at one price, not a universal condition.

2. (B). The oven is a good made to produce other goods (capital); the recipe is established knowledge that is non-rival, since another bakery can use it at the same time. (A) gets the oven right but treats the recipe as rival. (C) puts a made machine under land, which covers only natural resources. (D) confuses a machine with human effort. (E) confuses physical capital with money and calls knowledge a natural resource.

3. (D). An electrician's hour spent on one job cannot be spent on another, so labor is rival and scarce. (A), (B), (C) and (E) are all established knowledge, which is non-rival: one firm's use leaves the same amount for others. The distractors are tempting because they are all useful to production; usefulness is not the test.

4. Scoring:

  • Point 1 (Part A): State yes, and explain that the budget and workers are limited (scarce), so the workers and money used to extend library hours cannot also be used to repair roads; the city gives up some road repairs. Accept: the opportunity cost of longer library hours is the road repairs forgone. Does not earn: "yes, because it costs money" (no link to the alternative given up); "no, because the budget is fixed" (a fixed budget is the reason there is a trade-off).
  • Point 2 (Part B): Labor. Does not earn: capital (workers are people, not equipment made to produce goods); land (land covers only natural resources).

5. Scoring:

  • Point 1: State no, and explain that the method is established knowledge, which is non-rival, so one firm's use of it does not reduce the amount available for the other firm to use. Accept: knowledge is not used up when it is used, so both firms can use all of it at the same time. Does not earn: "no, because it is published" (says where it came from, not why use does not reduce it); "yes, because they compete" (competition for customers is not rivalry in the use of the method).

6. Scoring:

  • Point 1: State no, and explain that the family's resources, including time and income, are still limited relative to its wants, so it must still choose among alternatives and every choice has a trade-off. Accept: even with a lot of money, time is limited, so spending an hour on one activity means giving up another. Does not earn: "no, because everyone is poor in some way" (no link to limited resources and trade-offs); "yes, because they can afford everything" (wants are unlimited, so they cannot).

7. (B). Using the acre for corn rules out soybeans on that acre: a trade-off caused by scarce land. (A) mislabels a shortage, which a higher price removes, as permanent scarcity. (C) calls a machine land; a forklift is capital. (D) reverses the idea: a shared well-known design is non-rival. (E) gets the direction wrong; a new skill raises the quality of labor.

Ready for the next section?

Create a free account to read the rest of this free unit, save highlights, track your confidence and plan your revision.

Your next step

Put this topic into practice.

These tools belong to this free unit. Create an account to open them and save your progress.

Free-response practice · Sign up to open

AP Microeconomics Unit 1: Basic Economic Concepts. Free-response practice (Section II)

3 questions · Section II

Attempt the questions, check the scoring guidelines and record your own points.

Create free account to open this practice →
Multiple-choice practice · Sign up to open

AP Microeconomics Unit 1: Basic Economic Concepts. Multiple-choice practice (Section I)

20 questions · Section I

Check your understanding and get explanations after you submit.

Create free account to try this quiz →

Other units and paper downloads depend on your plan.

Already have an account? Sign in →

Give your revision a routine.

Build a timetable, tick off daily tasks, catch up on missed work and opt in to weekly email reviews. Connect with your teacher when you want to share your progress.