Interaction of heredity and environment
Maya and her twin sister Leah were born in Columbus, Ohio, and grew up in the same house, went to the same school and had the same piano teacher.
Both are anxious before tests.
Their cousin Dev was adopted as a baby by a family in Toledo and is calm under pressure, just like his birth mother, whom he has never met.
Stories like these raise the oldest question in psychology: how much of who we are comes from what we inherit, and how much from what happens to us?
This section explains why psychologists now answer "both, working together", how researchers try to untangle the two, and how one branch of thinking about heredity was misused to harm people.
Nature, nurture and their interaction
You need to know this idea in exactly these words:
- Heredity and environment: Heredity and environmental factors interact to shape behavior and mental processes.
- Heredity: Heredity, or “nature,” refers to genetic or predisposed characteristics that influence physical, behavioral, and mental traits and processes.
- Environmental factors: Environmental factors, or “nurture,” refers to the external factors that one experiences, such as family interactions or education.
- The evolutionary perspective: The evolutionary perspective explores how natural selection affects the expression of behavior and mental processes to increase survival and reproductive success. Some theorists have sought to apply principles of the evolutionary perspective in ways that discriminate against others (eugenics).
- Studying genes and behavior: Research on the effects of genes on individual behavior and mental processes is often conducted using twin studies, family studies, and adoption studies.
- Twin study: research that compares how alike identical twins (who share all their genes) and fraternal twins (who share about half, like other siblings) are on a trait.
- Family study: research that checks whether a trait is more common in a person's close biological relatives than in more distant relatives or the general population.
- Adoption study: research that compares adopted people with their biological relatives (shared genes) and their adoptive family (shared environment).
- Concordance rate: the percentage of pairs (for example, twin pairs) in which both members show a trait, given that one does.
"Interact" is the key word.
Heredity does not hand you a finished trait; it gives a range of possibilities, a predisposition, and the environment you meet decides where in that range you end up.
Height is a simple example.
Children inherit a likely adult height, but a child who is poorly fed reaches less of it.
Behavior works the same way.
A child born with a predisposition to be shy (a temperament that shows up in the first months of life) may become a confident adult if parents gently encourage new experiences, or a very withdrawn one if the family avoids every new situation.
The interaction also runs the other way: inherited traits shape the environments people meet.
An energetic, sociable toddler draws more conversation and play from adults, which builds language and social skill further.
A teen who inherited quick reflexes is more likely to join a team, where coaching sharpens them again.
So "nature or nurture" is the wrong question.
A better one is "how do these particular inherited tendencies and these particular experiences work together in this person?"
Back to Maya and Leah.
Their test anxiety could come from shared genes (heredity), from a shared home where grades were discussed every night (environment), or, most likely, from both.
Their cousin Dev shows why adoption matters to researchers: his calmness resembles a parent he shares genes with but never lived with, which points toward heredity for that trait, though one person can never prove it.
What you are not examined on. Specific genetics (genotype, phenotype, DNA, chromosomes, dominant and recessive gene expression) is outside this course's exam.
Talk about "genes" and "heredity" in general terms; you will never be asked to work out an inheritance pattern.
How researchers separate heredity from environment
You cannot run an experiment on heredity: no researcher can randomly assign children to genes or to families.
So psychologists use natural situations in which genes and environment vary in known ways.
Twin studies. Identical (monozygotic) twins come from one fertilized egg and share all their genes.
Fraternal (dizygotic) twins come from two eggs and share about half, like any brothers or sisters.
Both kinds of twins usually grow up in the same home at the same time.
If identical twins are more alike on a trait than fraternal twins are, the extra similarity is put down to their extra shared genes.
Researchers measure this with a concordance rate or a correlation between twins' scores.
Family studies. If a trait has a hereditary part, close biological relatives should show it more often than distant ones, and distant ones more than unrelated people.
The bar graph below shows pooled data of this kind for schizophrenia, a disorder you study in Unit 5.
The pattern rises with genetic relatedness: about 1 percent of the general population, about 9 percent of siblings, about 17 percent of fraternal twins and about 48 percent of identical twins of a person with schizophrenia (Gottesman, 1991, pooling many European family and twin studies).
Read it carefully.
Identical twins share all their genes, yet in about half of pairs only one twin develops the disorder, so genes alone cannot be the whole story.
This is the diathesis-stress idea you meet again in Unit 5: an inherited vulnerability plus environmental stress.
Adoption studies. Adopted children share genes with their birth parents and an environment with their adoptive parents.
If adopted children resemble their birth parents more on a trait, that points to heredity; if they resemble their adoptive family more, that points to environment.
What each design can and cannot show.
Design
What it can show
What it cannot show
Twin study
Whether extra genetic sharing (identical against fraternal) goes with extra similarity
Causation: twins cannot be randomly assigned, and identical twins may also be treated more alike
Family study
Whether a trait runs in families
Whether genes or the shared family environment cause it, since close relatives share both
Adoption study
Whether resemblance follows genes (birth family) or environment (adoptive family)
A clean split: adoption agencies often place children in homes like their birth families, and the prenatal environment comes from the birth mother
All three are correlational in logic.
Higher concordance in identical twins shows that heredity is related to a trait; it does not show that heredity causes it.
The strongest design combines two: twins who were separated early and reared apart.
- Participants. More than 100 sets of twins or triplets who had been separated early in life and reared apart, recruited from the United States, the United Kingdom and other countries from 1979 onward.
- What was done. Each participant spent about a week at the University of Minnesota completing intelligence tests, personality inventories, medical exams and interviews. Identical twins reared apart were compared with identical twins reared together.
- What was found. Identical twins reared apart were about as alike as identical twins reared together on many measures of personality, interests and attitudes. In this sample, about 70 percent of the variation in IQ scores was associated with genetic variation.
- What it shows. Heredity contributes strongly to differences between people in many traits, because twins who shared genes but not homes were still very alike.
- Limitation. Separated twins often grew up in similar kinds of homes (adoption placements tend to match), many had contact before testing, and the sample was volunteers who answered appeals for separated twins; similar environments would make heredity look stronger than it is. Later critics have also questioned how the data were analyzed.
The evolutionary perspective and its misuse
The evolutionary perspective asks why a behavior exists at all.
Natural selection, described by Charles Darwin in 1859, works like this: individuals vary; some variations are inherited; individuals whose inherited traits help them survive and reproduce leave more offspring; over many generations those traits become common.
Psychologists apply this to behavior and mental processes.
A preference for sweet and fatty foods helped ancestors who often went hungry store energy.
Fast fear of snakes and heights kept them alive.
A parent's strong attachment to an infant raised the infant's chance of surviving.
In each case, the evolutionary explanation is about survival and reproductive success, not about what a person wants in the moment.
Keep two limits in mind.
First, an evolutionary explanation of why a tendency exists does not mean the tendency is good or fixed; a taste for sweet foods that helped ancestors can harm health in a world of cheap sugar.
Second, the evolutionary perspective has been misused.
In the late 1800s Francis Galton, a cousin of Darwin, coined the term eugenics (in 1883) for "improving" humanity by encouraging some people to reproduce and preventing others.
In the early 1900s eugenics was used to justify laws in many US states allowing forced sterilization of people labeled "unfit", often people who were poor, disabled, immigrants or people of color.
In Buck v.
Bell (1927), the US Supreme Court upheld Virginia's forced sterilization law, and tens of thousands of Americans were sterilized under such laws.
Eugenic ideas also fed the Nazi program of sterilization and murder.
This is what the course means by applying evolutionary principles "in ways that discriminate against others".
You meet the misuse of intelligence tests, which grew from the same movement, in Unit 2.
Perspectives in this section. The biological perspective explains behavior through genes, the brain and body chemistry; the evolutionary perspective explains why inherited tendencies exist through natural selection; the sociocultural and behavioral perspectives stress environment, family, culture and learning.
An exam answer that names the right perspective for an explanation earns credit in concept questions.
Used again in: temperament and attachment (Unit 3); intelligence and the misuse of tests (Unit 2); the biological and evolutionary perspectives on disorders and the diathesis-stress model (Unit 5); biological preparedness in learning (Unit 3).
- The free-response section has two questions of 7 points each. The Article Analysis Question (AAQ) has parts A. to F.: A Research Method 1, B Research Variable 1, C Statistic Interpretation 1, D Ethical Guidelines 1, E Generalizability 1, F Argumentation 0-2. The Evidence-Based Question (EBQ) has A. Claim 1, B. i. Evidence 1 and ii. Explanation and Application 0-2, C. i. Evidence 1 and ii. Explanation and Application 0-2.
- Each point is earned on its own: no levels, no half points. Only AAQ F, EBQ B(ii) and EBQ C(ii) can earn 2.
- A definition alone never earns. Use the idea to the people or data in front of you.
- Contradictions cost the point: give one method, one guideline, one claim, never a list.
- Part B wants the measure the researchers used (a score on a named scale, a count, a time), not a description of the concept.
- Part C wants what the difference means in the study, with direction; a significant difference is unlikely to be due to chance.
- Part D needs a guideline the summary actually describes, plus how it was applied.
- Part E needs a claim, a population and evidence about who the participants were; sample size never earns.
- Evidence in the EBQ is a cited result, not a method or participant detail. The reasoning point needs a course concept woven into the explanation, a different one in Part C, and never a word the sources print.
- Write complete sentences, in order, each part once.
Answering questions on heredity and environment
Questions here test two skills.
The first is concept application: deciding whether a detail in a scene is heredity or environment, or which perspective explains it.
The second is research reasoning about twin, family and adoption studies: why they are not experiments, what their numbers show and what they cannot show.
Rafael's father and grandfather were both talented sprinters.
Rafael is fast too, and his high school track coach in Phoenix gives him extra practice starts every afternoon.
Explain how heredity and environmental factors may each have contributed to Rafael's sprinting.
Full-credit answer: Heredity: Rafael may have inherited predisposed physical characteristics, such as a build suited to sprinting, from his father and grandfather, because the trait runs in his biological family.
Environmental factors: the extra practice starts his coach gives him are an external experience that trains his speed further.
The two interact, because his inherited speed probably led the coach to give him the extra practice in the first place.
Scoring. Each concept earns only when it is tied to a detail of the scene: heredity to the biological relatives, environment to the coaching.
Does not earn: "Heredity is nature and environment is nurture" (a definition with no link to Rafael).
Weaker answer: "Rafael is fast because of both nature and nurture."
This earns nothing: it names the concepts but never says which detail of Rafael's life shows each.
Researchers in Ohio gave 220 pairs of adolescent twins (130 identical pairs, 90 fraternal pairs) a questionnaire measuring sensation seeking.
The correlation between twins' scores was +0.58 for identical twins and +0.24 for fraternal twins.
A. Identify the research method used in the study.
B. Explain what the difference between the two correlations suggests about heredity and sensation seeking.
Part A (Research Method, 1 point): The researchers used a correlational study (a twin study).
Does not earn: "an experiment", because twins cannot be randomly assigned to be identical or fraternal and nothing was manipulated; "a twin study" alone, which is a design and not one of the five research methods; "a correlational study and an experiment" (contradiction).
Part B (1 point): Identical twins, who share all their genes, were more alike in sensation seeking than fraternal twins, who share about half, so heredity is related to sensation seeking.
Because the study is correlational, it shows a relationship with heredity, not that genes cause the trait.
Does not earn: "Genes cause sensation seeking" (a causal claim the design cannot support); "+0.58 is bigger than +0.24" (restates the numbers without saying what they mean).
Weaker answer: "Identical twins are the same."
This scores 0: it describes twins, not what the data show about heredity.
Based on the bar graph of lifetime risk of schizophrenia, which statement is best supported?
The risk rises as genetic relatedness rises (1, 9, 17, then 48 percent), which supports a hereditary contribution.
But identical twins share all their genes and the risk is still only about 48 percent, so environmental factors must also matter.
An answer that says "schizophrenia is genetic" ignores the second half; an answer that says "the graph shows genes cause schizophrenia" claims causation from correlational data.
When a question asks why a twin, family or adoption study is not an experiment, the answer that earns is that the researchers cannot randomly assign people to their genes or their families (nothing is manipulated).
Then say what the data do show: higher similarity or concordance in identical twins shows heredity is related to the trait, not that it causes it.
- Calling a twin study an experiment because it has two groups. Groups alone do not make an experiment; the researcher must manipulate a variable and randomly assign people. The two groups make it look like one, which is why the slip is common.
- Saying higher concordance in identical twins "proves" genes cause the trait. It shows a relationship; identical twins may also be treated more alike, and about half of identical twins of a person with schizophrenia do not develop it.
- Writing "nature versus nurture" as if one wins. The course wording is that they interact; good answers show how one shapes the effect of the other.
- Defining heredity or environment without applying it. "Heredity is genetic traits" earns nothing; "Rafael may have inherited his build from his sprinting father" earns. Definitions feel safe to write, which is why students write them.
- Calling eugenics a finding of the evolutionary perspective. It was a misuse of evolutionary ideas to discriminate against people, and the course wants you to name it as a misuse.
Check your understanding
1. Keisha's parents both taught her to read before kindergarten, and she now reads two grade levels ahead. Which of the following best describes the parents' reading lessons? (A) A predisposed characteristic that influences Keisha's reading (B) A concordance rate between Keisha and her parents (C) An example of natural selection acting on Keisha's reading (D) An environmental factor that influences Keisha's reading Total [1]
2. A researcher finds that depression is more common among the brothers and sisters of people with depression than in the general population. Which of the following best explains why this family study cannot show that depression is inherited? (A) Brothers and sisters share both genes and a family environment, so either could explain the similarity. (B) Family studies cannot measure depression with a reliable questionnaire. (C) The researcher did not use a large enough sample of brothers and sisters. (D) Brothers and sisters share none of their genes with each other. Total [1]
3. A psychologist argues that people learn to fear snakes faster than flowers because ancestors who quickly learned to avoid snakes were more likely to survive and have children. Which perspective does this explanation reflect? (A) Humanistic (B) Psychodynamic (C) Evolutionary (D) Sociocultural Total [1]
4. Researchers studied 40 adopted adolescents in Texas. Each had been adopted before 6 months of age. The table shows the correlations between the adolescents' scores on a verbal reasoning test and the scores of their birth mothers and their adoptive mothers.
Correlations Between Adolescents' Verbal Reasoning Scores and Mothers' Scores
Mother
Correlation with adolescent's score
Birth mother
+0.38
Adoptive mother
+0.12
A. Identify the research method used in the study.
B. Describe what the difference between the two correlations indicates about the adolescents' verbal reasoning scores.
C. Explain the extent to which the findings may or may not be generalizable to all adopted adolescents in the United States, using specific and relevant evidence from the study.
Total [3]
5. Tomás grew up speaking Spanish at home in Albuquerque and English at school. He is now fluent in both, while his identical twin brother, raised by an aunt in a town where only English was spoken, speaks only English.
A. Explain how environmental factors relate to the difference between Tomás and his brother.
B. Explain how this case shows the interaction of heredity and environment.
Total [2]
6. In a twin study of a reading disability, both twins had the disability in 42 of 60 identical pairs and in 15 of 50 fraternal pairs. What is the concordance rate for the fraternal pairs? (A) 15% (B) 30% (C) 42% (D) 70% Total [1]
7. In the early 1900s, some US states passed laws allowing people judged to be "unfit" to be sterilized without their consent, and supporters claimed the laws would improve the population.
Explain how these laws reflect a misuse of the evolutionary perspective.
Total [1]
Answers
1. (D). The reading lessons are external experiences in Keisha's family, so they are environmental factors. (A) is tempting because her reading is a trait, but the lessons are not inherited. (B) a concordance rate is a research statistic for pairs, not a family activity. (C) natural selection works across generations through survival and reproduction, not through one child's lessons.
2. (A). Close relatives share both genes and a home, so a family study cannot tell which one produces the similarity. (B) is tempting because measurement matters, but depression can be measured reliably. (C) a larger sample would not separate genes from environment. (D) is false: full siblings share about half their genes.
3. (C). Survival and reproductive advantage for ancestors is the evolutionary perspective's explanation. (A) humanistic focuses on growth and free will. (B) psychodynamic focuses on unconscious conflicts. (D) sociocultural would point to cultural teaching about snakes, which is tempting but is not what the psychologist argues.
4. Scoring:
- Part A (Research Method, 1 point): The researchers used a correlational study (an adoption study measured with correlations). Earns: "correlational study". Does not earn: "an experiment" (nothing was manipulated and adoption was not randomly assigned); "an adoption study" alone, a design and not one of the five methods; two methods named.
- Part B (Statistic Interpretation, 1 point): The adolescents' verbal reasoning scores were more closely related to the scores of their birth mothers, with whom they share genes but did not live, than to the scores of their adoptive mothers, which suggests that heredity is more strongly related to verbal reasoning than the adoptive home is in this sample. Earns: "the scores were more similar to the birth mothers' scores than the adoptive mothers'". Does not earn: "+0.38 and +0.12" (restated); "birth mothers caused higher scores" (causal claim, and correlation is about similarity, not level).
- Part C (Generalizability, 1 point): The findings may not generalize to all adopted adolescents in the United States, because all 40 participants lived in Texas and were adopted before 6 months of age, so adolescents adopted later or elsewhere may differ. Earns: a claim plus a population plus participant evidence (one state; adopted as infants). Does not earn: "Only 40 participants is too small" (sample size is not evidence of who was sampled); "It is generalizable" with no population or evidence.
5. Scoring:
- Part A (1 point): Tomás's fluency in Spanish comes from an external factor he experienced, the Spanish spoken at home, which his brother did not experience in an English-only town; because the twins share all their genes, the language difference must come from the environment. Does not earn: "Environment is nurture" (definition only).
- Part B (1 point): Both twins inherited the same capacity to learn language (heredity), but which languages each actually learned depended on the languages around him (environment), so the inherited capacity was expressed differently in the two environments. Does not earn: "It shows both nature and nurture" (no link to the twins).
6. (B). 15 of 50 pairs is 15 ÷ 50 = 0.30, or 30%. (A) is the count of pairs, not a percentage. (C) is the count for identical pairs. (D) is the identical-twin rate, 42 ÷ 60 = 70%.
7. Scoring (1 point): Supporters took the evolutionary idea that traits passed on through reproduction shape a population and used it to justify preventing people they labeled unfit from reproducing; this is eugenics, which discriminated against poor, disabled and minority people and was upheld in Buck v. Bell (1927). Does not earn: "It was unethical" with no link to evolutionary ideas; "It is natural selection" (forced sterilization is a human policy, not natural selection).