Skip to content
AP U.S. Government and PoliticsFoundations of American Democracy
Explore another subject
AP · us-governmentONE COMPLETE FREE SECTION

Ideals of Democracy

AP U.S. Government and Politics · Foundations of American Democracy

Your course level

Everyone in this class reads the same notes.

The sample stays complete. Sign up when you’re ready to continue the unit.

0 highlighted

Ideals of Democracy

Every time a city council member takes an oath, a court strikes down a law, or a citizen votes in a school board election, an old set of ideas is being put to work.

Those ideas explain why Americans expect their government to protect certain rights, why it needs their consent, and why no official, not even the president, can do whatever he or she wants.

This section teaches the four democratic ideals the whole course rests on and the three founding texts that state them: the Declaration of Independence, the U.S. Constitution and the Gettysburg Address.

Every later unit (Congress, the courts, civil liberties, elections) applies these ideas, so learn them precisely now.

The four democratic ideals

You need to know that "The U.S. government is based on the following democratic ideals: Natural rights (all people have certain rights that cannot be taken away); A social contract (an implicit agreement among the people in a society to give up some freedoms to maintain social order); Popular sovereignty (all government power comes from the consent of its people); Limited government (a government’s power cannot be absolute)".

Each ideal answers a different question about government.

  • Natural rights answers "what does a person have before any government exists?" The English philosopher John Locke, in his Second Treatise of Government (1690), argued that people are born with rights to life, liberty and property. A government does not grant these rights; it exists to protect them. That is why the idea is so powerful: if a right comes from government, government can take it back, but if it comes from being human, a government that takes it away has broken its purpose.
  • A social contract answers "why should anyone obey government at all?" Without government, Thomas Hobbes argued, life would be a constant struggle in which no one was safe. People therefore agree, without ever signing anything, to give up some freedom (the freedom to settle disputes by force, to drive at any speed) in exchange for order and protection. The contract is implicit: you accept it by living in the society and enjoying its protection.
  • Popular sovereignty answers "where does government get its power?" Sovereignty means final authority. Popular sovereignty places that authority in the people, so government power is legitimate only when the people consent to it, usually through elections and a written constitution they approve.
  • Limited government answers "how much power may government have?" The answer is: never absolute. Government may act only within the powers the people grant it, and it must leave certain areas of life (speech, worship, a fair trial) alone.

The ideals fit together as a chain.

People hold natural rights; to protect them they enter a social contract; the government created by that contract gets its power from the people (popular sovereignty); and because the people gave only some of their freedom, the government's power stays limited.

How limited government is ensured

Saying government should be limited is easy; keeping it limited is hard.

You need to know that "The ideal of limited government is ensured by the interaction of these principles: Separation of powers; Checks and balances; Federalism; Republicanism".

The diagram below shows how the four principles sit under the ideal of limited government.

Diagram of the four democratic ideals the U.S. government is based on, natural rights, a social contract, popular sovereignty and limited government, in a row of boxes. Lines run from the limited government box down to four boxes for the principles that ensure it: separation of powers, checks and balances, federalism and republicanism.
Diagram of the four democratic ideals the U.S. government is based on, natural rights, a social contract, popular sovereignty and limited government, in a row of boxes. Lines run from the limited government box down to four boxes for the principles that ensure it: separation of powers, checks and balances, federalism and republicanism.
  • Separation of powers divides national power among three branches: Congress makes the laws (Article I), the president carries them out (Article II), and the courts interpret them (Article III). No single person or body holds all three jobs.
  • Checks and balances lets each branch limit the others: the president can veto a bill, Congress can override the veto with a two-thirds vote in each chamber, and the courts can strike down an unconstitutional law. Section 1.6 teaches these in full.
  • Federalism divides power between the national government and the states, so that neither level holds all of it. Sections 1.7 to 1.9 teach it in full.
  • Republicanism is a system in which the people elect representatives to make laws for them. Officials who must face voters again can be removed peacefully at the next election, which limits what they dare to do.

The key word in that statement is interaction.

No principle works alone.

Separation of powers would mean little if one branch could simply ignore the others; checks and balances give each branch a weapon to defend its share.

Federalism adds a second line of division, between levels, and republicanism ties every elected official back to the voters.

Recent exams have asked you to apply these ideals to a Supreme Court holding, so practice saying not only what an ideal means but what a real action did to it.

The three founding texts

You need to know that "The Declaration of Independence, drafted by Thomas Jefferson (with help from Adams and Franklin), restates the philosophy of natural rights, and provides a foundation for popular sovereignty.

The U.S. Constitution, drafted by James Madison at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia that was led by George Washington (with important contributions from Hamilton and members of the “Grand Committee”), is an example of a social contract and establishes a system of limited government.

The Constitution provides the blueprint for a unique form of democratic government in the United States.

The Gettysburg Address, written by Abraham Lincoln and delivered during the U.S. Civil War, reaffirmed equality and popular sovereignty as defining foundations of democracy."

The three texts span nearly ninety years, and each does a different job: the Declaration justifies breaking away, the Constitution builds a government, and the Gettysburg Address restates the nation's purpose in the middle of a war that threatened to destroy it.

The picture below is a modern drawing made for these notes, in the style of an old engraving.

It shows the kind of scene Lincoln faced on November 19, 1863: thousands of people gathered at the new soldiers' cemetery, with the graves of the dead around them.

Keep the setting in mind when you read the Address: Lincoln was speaking over the graves of men killed defending a government "of the people".

A modern drawing made for these notes, in the style of an old engraving: a huge crowd of civilians and Union soldiers gathered around a wooden speakers' platform on the hills at Gettysburg in November 1863, with new rows of graves in the foreground, as a speaker addresses them at the dedication of the soldiers' cemetery.
A modern drawing made for these notes, in the style of an old engraving: a huge crowd of civilians and Union soldiers gathered around a wooden speakers' platform on the hills at Gettysburg in November 1863, with new rows of graves in the foreground, as a speaker addresses them at the dedication of the soldiers' cemetery.
Foundational document: The Declaration of Independence

Author and date. Drafted by Thomas Jefferson, revised by a committee of five that included John Adams and Benjamin Franklin, and adopted by the Second Continental Congress on July 4, 1776.

Occasion. Fighting with Britain had begun in April 1775.

Congress voted for independence on July 2, 1776, and the Declaration explained to the world why the colonies were justified in leaving.

The argument in plain words. All people have rights that no government may take away.

Governments are set up to protect those rights, and their power comes from the consent of the people they govern.

When a government destroys the rights it was set up to protect, the people may change it or abolish it and set up a new one.

King George III, the document says, has repeatedly abused the colonists' rights, so the colonies are now free and independent states.

Most of its length is a list of grievances: taxes without consent, trial without a jury, soldiers kept among the people in peacetime.

Short extracts.

  • "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness." This is natural rights: "unalienable" means the rights cannot be given away or taken away.
  • "Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed". This is popular sovereignty: power is "just" only when the people consent.

Evidence you can use. (1) The consent of the governed: evidence for arguments that power belongs to the people and that elections, or a more participatory system, keep government legitimate.

(2) The right to "alter or to abolish" a destructive government: evidence that the people, not rulers, are the final authority, useful in essays on popular sovereignty and on reform movements.

(3) The grievance list (taxation without consent, no trial by jury): evidence for limited government and for why the Bill of Rights later guarded these rights.

Most often confused with. The Constitution.

The Declaration states ideals and breaks from Britain; it creates no government and has no legal force as law.

The Constitution builds the government and is the supreme law.

If your evidence is a power or an institution, it comes from the Constitution, not the Declaration.

Foundational document: The U.S. Constitution as a social contract

Author and date. Drafted mainly by James Madison at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia (May 25 to September 17, 1787), which George Washington led as presiding officer; Alexander Hamilton contributed, and committees such as the "Grand Committee" (one delegate from each state present, which in July 1787 worked out the compromise over representation) settled the hardest disputes.

Signed September 17, 1787; in effect in 1788 after nine states ratified.

Occasion. The Articles of Confederation had left the national government too weak to tax, to enforce laws or to put down rebellion (section 1.4).

The argument in plain words. The Preamble opens "We the People of the United States", so the people, not the states or a king, establish the government.

The people grant specific powers to three branches, divide power between nation and states, and keep rights the government may not touch (the Bill of Rights, added in 1791).

That is a social contract written down: the people give up some freedom, accept laws and taxes, and in return receive order and protection, but only on the terms written in the document.

Short extracts.

  • "We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America." The people are the authors; the listed purposes are what they receive for their consent.
  • Article I, Section 9: "The Privilege of the Writ of Habeas Corpus shall not be suspended, unless when in Cases of Rebellion or Invasion the public Safety may require it." Even before the Bill of Rights, the Constitution limited what government could do to a person it held.

Evidence you can use. (1) The Preamble's "We the People": popular sovereignty and the social contract.

(2) Enumerated powers in Article I, Section 8: evidence that national power is limited to listed subjects.

(3) The amendment process in Article V: evidence that the people, through their representatives and the states, can rewrite the contract.

Most often confused with. The Declaration (above), and the Articles of Confederation, which was the first written plan of government but was an agreement among states, not among "the People".

Foundational document: The Gettysburg Address

Author and date. Written and delivered by President Abraham Lincoln on November 19, 1863, at the dedication of the Soldiers' National Cemetery at Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, four and a half months after the battle there (July 1 to 3, 1863).

Occasion. The Civil War was testing whether a government based on the people's consent could survive the secession of eleven states.

The main speech of the day was a two-hour oration by Edward Everett; Lincoln's address is about 270 words.

The argument in plain words. The nation was founded on the idea that all people are created equal.

The war is a test of whether any nation built on that idea can last.

The dead soldiers gave their lives so that it could; the living must finish their work.

That work is a "new birth of freedom", so that government by the people does not disappear from the world.

Short extracts.

  • "Four score and seven years ago our fathers brought forth on this continent, a new nation, conceived in Liberty, and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal." Eighty-seven years before 1863 is 1776: Lincoln dates the nation from the Declaration and its promise of equality, not from the Constitution.
  • "government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth." This is popular sovereignty in its most famous form: power comes from the people, is used by them through their representatives, and serves them.

Evidence you can use. (1) "dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal": evidence that equality is a founding ideal, useful in essays on civil rights and on the federal government protecting rights against states.

(2) "government of the people, by the people, for the people": evidence for popular sovereignty and for participatory arguments.

(3) The "new birth of freedom": evidence that the meaning of the founding ideals grew after the founding, which leads to the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Amendments (Unit 3).

Most often confused with. The Emancipation Proclamation, Lincoln's other required document.

The Proclamation (January 1, 1863) was a presidential order, issued under the president's war powers, declaring free the enslaved people in the states then in rebellion; the Address (November 1863) is a speech about the meaning of the nation and makes no legal change.

Used again in: natural rights and limited government with civil liberties (Unit 3); popular sovereignty with elections and participation (Unit 5); republicanism with Congress and representation (Unit 2); the Gettysburg Address with presidential persuasion and the bully pulpit (Unit 2) and with equal protection (Unit 3).

How the points work
  • The free-response section has four questions, always in this order: Question 1 Concept Application (3 points), Question 2 Quantitative Analysis (4 points), Question 3 SCOTUS Comparison (4 points) and Question 4 Argument Essay (6 points).
  • Every part is worth 1 point, except Question 3 Part B (1 or 2 points) and the essay's evidence row (0 to 3 points). There are no levels and no half points.
  • Identify: name one thing (one clause, ideal, year or state). One only.
  • Describe: say what the concept, power or trend is and does, in the terms of the scenario or data. A bare name earns nothing.
  • Explain: give the action or cause and then its effect on the target the part names; finish the chain with "so", "because" or "which means".
  • Draw a conclusion: a direction in the data plus a named actor or concept plus what follows from it.
  • Compare and Define: both sides in one sentence; the complete meaning of the term.
  • Question 3 Part B: a fact or the holding of the required case alone earns 1; facts from both cases joined in one explanation of why the holdings match or differ earn 2.
  • The essay's rows: A, a claim with a line of reasoning; B, evidence (two specific pieces, one from a listed document, for all 3 points); C, reasoning that explains how the evidence supports the claim; D, the other position with its reason, then a rebuttal or refutation.
  • Answer from the scenario or data ("In the scenario, ..."). Give the one answer asked for. Copying the prompt earns nothing; write complete sentences.
Key terms
  • Natural rights: all people have certain rights that cannot be taken away
  • A social contract: an implicit agreement among the people in a society to give up some freedoms to maintain social order
  • Popular sovereignty: all government power comes from the consent of its people
  • Limited government: a government’s power cannot be absolute
  • Republicanism: the democratic principle that the will of the people is reflected in government debates and decisions by their representatives
Worked example 1: describing an ideal from a document (a 1-point part)

Describe the democratic ideal reflected in the Declaration of Independence's statement that governments derive "their just powers from the consent of the governed."

Answer: The statement reflects popular sovereignty: the government's authority is legitimate only because the people agree to it, so power comes from the people, not from a king or from birth.

Part A, 1 point. Accept: government power rests on the people's consent; the people are the final source of authority.

Does not earn: "popular sovereignty" with nothing more (a bare name does not describe); "natural rights" (that is the "unalienable Rights" passage, a different idea); "democracy" (too vague).

Many Question 3 Part C points ask you to tie a holding to an ideal.

The next example uses a real case you are not required to know, so you can see the method on unfamiliar facts.

Worked example 2: tying an ideal to a holding (Explain, full and weaker answers)

In West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette (1943), the Supreme Court ruled 6-3 that a state could not force public school students to salute the flag and recite the Pledge of Allegiance.

Explain how the holding in Barnette reflects the ideal of limited government.

Full answer: Limited government means a government's power cannot be absolute.

In Barnette, the Court held that West Virginia could not compel students to salute the flag, so the state's power over what students say or believe in school stopped at the First Amendment, which keeps government from forcing expression on an individual.

1 point. Earns: the ideal defined in one clause, then the action (the Court struck down the compulsory salute) and its effect (the state's power was limited by a right).

Accept: the holding shows that even a popular government policy must yield to individual rights, which keeps government from absolute control over citizens' beliefs.

Weaker answer: "Limited government means that the government's power is not absolute and it has to follow the Constitution.

This is important in a democracy."

This scores 0: it defines the ideal but never says what Barnette did, so there is no link to the case.

Worked example 3: the Gettysburg Address as essay evidence (Rows B and C)

An essay asks whether popular sovereignty or limited government is the more important foundation of American democracy.

A student arguing for popular sovereignty writes this body paragraph.

Paragraph: In the Gettysburg Address of November 1863, Abraham Lincoln told the crowd at the new military cemetery that the Union soldiers had died so that "government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth."

[Row B: a listed document, described by its content] Lincoln was defending the Union in a war that could have ended it, and he chose to describe what was at stake as the people's power to govern themselves.

Because he placed the people's rule at the center of what the war was for, the speech shows that Americans have treated consent of the people as the purpose that makes the whole system worth defending, so popular sovereignty is the more basic foundation.

[Row C: explains how the evidence supports the claim]

Why it works: the evidence is specific (the quoted phrase, the occasion, the date), so it could come only from the Gettysburg Address.

The reasoning sentence uses "Because ...

so", which ties the evidence to the claim.

A paragraph that said only "Lincoln's Gettysburg Address talks about democracy" would earn at most 1 point in Row B and nothing in Row C.

Exam tip

When a part names an ideal (natural rights, limited government, popular sovereignty, republicanism), define it in one short clause and then spend the rest of your answer on the link: what the actor or the Court did, and what that did to the ideal.

Answers that only define the ideal, however correctly, do not earn the point.

Common mistakes
  • Treating "democratic ideal" as a reference to the Democratic Party. It is tempting because the words match, but here "democratic" means rule by the people. Fix: name the ideal (popular sovereignty, natural rights) and leave parties out.
  • Mixing up popular sovereignty and natural rights. Both appear in the same paragraph of the Declaration, which makes the slip easy. Fix: rights people are born with are natural rights; power coming from the people's consent is popular sovereignty.
  • Calling the Declaration of Independence the law that created the government. It feels like a founding charter, but it created no institutions. Fix: powers and branches come from the Constitution.
  • Treating limited government as one of the four principles in the diagram. It is tempting because the ideal and the principles are always taught together, but limited government is the ideal; separation of powers, checks and balances, federalism and republicanism are the principles that ensure it.
  • Defining republicanism as "being a Republican". The party name makes it tempting. Fix: republicanism is rule through elected representatives.

Check your understanding

1. In 1620, before landing in Massachusetts, the passengers of the Mayflower signed an agreement to form a "civil Body Politick" and to obey the laws it made. Which democratic ideal does this agreement best reflect? (A) Natural rights, because the passengers kept their rights to life and liberty (B) A social contract, because the passengers agreed to give up some freedom and obey laws in return for order (C) Federalism, because the passengers divided power between a colony and England (D) Separation of powers, because the passengers created three branches of government

Total [1]

2. "Four score and seven years ago our fathers brought forth on this continent, a new nation, conceived in Liberty, and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal." Abraham Lincoln, the Gettysburg Address, November 19, 1863 Which of the following best describes the purpose of this passage? (A) To announce that enslaved people in the states then in rebellion were free (B) To argue that the national government should have more power than the states (C) To connect the nation's founding with the ideal of equality stated in the Declaration of Independence (D) To describe the powers that the Constitution gives to the president in wartime

Total [1]

3. Identify one principle that ensures the ideal of limited government in the U.S. system.

Total [1]

4. Explain how the Declaration of Independence provides a foundation for popular sovereignty.

Total [1]

5. A state legislature passes a law requiring every public library to remove any book that a state board labels objectionable. A group of parents and authors sues, and a federal judge blocks the law, ruling that it likely violates the First Amendment. Explain how the judge's ruling reflects the democratic ideal of natural rights.

Total [1]

6. Americans have long debated which ideal matters most to their system of government. Develop an argument as to whether popular sovereignty or limited government is the more important foundation of the U.S. system of government. Use at least one piece of evidence from one of the following foundational documents:

  • The Declaration of Independence
  • Gettysburg Address
  • Federalist No. 51 In your response you should do the following:
  • Respond to the prompt with a defensible claim or thesis that establishes a line of reasoning.
  • Support your claim with at least two pieces of specific and relevant evidence. One piece of evidence must come from one of the foundational documents listed. A second piece of evidence can come from any other foundational document not used as your first piece of evidence or it may be from your knowledge of course concepts.
  • Use reasoning to explain why your evidence supports your claim or thesis.
  • Respond to an opposing or alternate perspective using rebuttal or refutation.

Total [6]

Answers

1. (B). The passengers agreed to accept laws made by their own body in exchange for an orderly society: a social contract, in written form. (A) is tempting because rights are kept, but the agreement is about giving up freedom to obey laws. (C) is wrong because no division between levels of government is described. (D) is wrong because no branches are created.

2. (C). "Four score and seven years ago" is 1776, the year of the Declaration, and the passage repeats its claim that all men are created equal. (A) describes the Emancipation Proclamation, the twin document. (B) is about federalism, which the passage does not mention. (D) is tempting because the speech was given in wartime, but it describes no presidential power.

3. Part A, 1 point. Checks and balances. Accept: separation of powers; federalism; republicanism. Does not earn: limited government (that is the ideal itself); natural rights (an ideal, not a principle); a list of two or more principles when one is asked for.

4. 1 point. The Declaration states that governments derive "their just powers from the consent of the governed," so it treats the people as the source of all legitimate authority, which is the idea of popular sovereignty that the Constitution later built on with "We the People". Accept: the Declaration says the people may alter or abolish a government that destroys their rights, which places final authority in the people. Does not earn: "the Declaration says all men are created equal" (that is equality and natural rights, with no link to the source of power); a definition of popular sovereignty with no reference to the Declaration.

5. 1 point. Natural rights are rights people hold that cannot be taken away; the judge blocked the state from removing books, which protected the authors' and readers' freedom of expression from a government that tried to restrict it, treating that freedom as a right the state could not simply remove. Accept: the ruling treats freedom of speech as a right that exists apart from what a legislature wants, so the majority cannot take it away by passing a law. Does not earn: a definition of natural rights with no reference to the ruling; "the judge used checks and balances" (true of the process, but the part asks about natural rights).

6. A model essay arguing for popular sovereignty, with its rows.

Popular sovereignty is the more important foundation of the U.S. system, because every limit on government, every office and every law draws its authority from the consent of the people, so without it limited government would have no source.

[Row A]

The Declaration of Independence states that governments derive "their just powers from the consent of the governed" and that the people may alter or abolish a government that destroys their rights.

[Row B: a listed document, described specifically] This means that the colonists did not justify independence by pointing to a limit Britain had crossed; they justified it by saying the people are the final authority over any government.

Because the founding act of the nation rested on the people's right to make and unmake governments, popular sovereignty came first and the other ideals were built on it.

[Row C]

Lincoln's Gettysburg Address, delivered in November 1863 at the cemetery for the Union dead, said the war was being fought so that "government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth."

[Row B: a second piece of specific evidence, from another foundational document] In the nation's worst crisis, the president defined what was worth dying for as the people's power to govern themselves, which shows that popular sovereignty is the purpose of the system, not just one feature of it.

Some argue that limited government matters more, because Madison in Federalist No. 51 warned that majorities can abuse power and designed checks and balances to stop them.

However, those checks were themselves created by the people when they ratified the Constitution, and the people can change them through Article V, so the limits Madison praised exist only because the people chose them; the source of the limits is still popular sovereignty.

[Row D: the other position with its reason, then a rebuttal]

Rows: A 1, B 3 (two specific pieces supporting the claim, one from a listed document), C 1, D 1 = 6.

A version that ended "some people think limited government is more important, but I disagree" would earn 0 in Row D, because it gives no reason for the other side and no rebuttal: 5 points at most.

A student could equally earn 6 arguing for limited government, using Federalist No. 51 and the Bill of Rights.

Ready for the next section?

Create a free account to read the rest of this free unit, save highlights, track your confidence and plan your revision.

Your next step

Put this topic into practice.

These tools belong to this free unit. Create an account to open them and save your progress.

Free-response practice · Sign up to open

AP United States Government and Politics Unit 1: Foundations of American Democracy. Free-response practice (Section II)

4 questions · Section II

Attempt the questions, check the scoring guidelines and record your own points.

Create free account to open this practice →
Multiple-choice practice · Sign up to open

AP United States Government and Politics Unit 1: Foundations of American Democracy. Multiple-choice practice (Section I)

20 questions · Section I

Check your understanding and get explanations after you submit.

Create free account to try this quiz →

Other units and paper downloads depend on your plan.

Already have an account? Sign in →

Give your revision a routine.

Build a timetable, tick off daily tasks, catch up on missed work and opt in to weekly email reviews. Connect with your teacher when you want to share your progress.