Contextualizing Period 1; Native American Societies Before European Contact
Period 1 runs from 1491 to 1607.
The first date is the year before Christopher Columbus reached the Caribbean, so the period opens with the Americas as they were before Europeans arrived.
The second is the founding of Jamestown, the first lasting English colony, so the period closes just as English colonization begins.
Between the two dates, three stories unfold: the many Native American societies of North America go on developing in their own ways; Europeans, led by Spain and Portugal, cross the Atlantic and build the first empires in the Americas; and contact among Europeans, Native Americans and Africans changes all three worlds through the movement of plants, animals, diseases, people and ideas.
This first section does two jobs.
It gives you the context for the whole unit (what Europe, Africa and the Americas were like in 1491, and why that matters for everything that follows), and it teaches the four historical developments about Native societies before contact.
You need both: the exam asks you to explain how Native peoples "interacted with the natural environment in North America", and it asks you to set any later development in its context.
Native societies are also the actors in later sections, so what you learn here about their diversity returns in every unit up to the end of the nineteenth century.
- The short-answer section has three required questions, each with a source: Short-answer Question 1 gives two historians' excerpts ("Source 1" and "Source 2"), Question 2 one primary text, Question 3 one image, map or chart. Each opens "Respond to parts A, B, and C."
- Every part is worth 1 point, earned on its own. No half points, no levels.
- Briefly describe: name the specific thing and give its relevant characteristics, more than a term.
- Briefly explain: say how or why, with a specific named piece of evidence and the link back to the task (answer, evidence, link).
- Evidence must fall inside the part's date window, and in Question 1 it must not already be in the excerpts.
- The document-based question (DBQ) has seven points: thesis 1, contextualization 1, evidence from the documents 2, evidence beyond the documents 1, sourcing 1, complex understanding 1.
- The long essay question (LEQ) has six: thesis 1, contextualization 1, evidence 2, analysis and reasoning 2.
- Points are awarded row by row, never by levels. One piece of evidence earns one row only: the development you use for context cannot also be your evidence beyond the documents.
- Write complete sentences in paragraphs, never bullets.
Why 1491? The context for European encounters
To explain the context for European encounters, you need to see three worlds at once in 1491.
The Americas. People had lived in the Americas for at least 15,000 years, and some evidence points earlier.
Their descendants had spread over two continents and developed hundreds of distinct societies speaking several hundred languages.
Historians' estimates of the population north of present-day Mexico in 1491 vary widely, most falling between about 2 million and 7 million; central Mexico and the Andes held far more people.
These societies were not frozen in time.
Cities had risen and fallen (Cahokia on the Mississippi was largely empty by about 1350), droughts had pushed peoples to move, and nations formed alliances, traded over long distances and fought one another.
Europe. Western Europe in 1491 was a group of competing monarchies, crowded and short of land, recovering from the Black Death of the 1340s and hungry for the spices, silk and gold of Asia and Africa.
The Ottoman Turks had taken Constantinople in 1453 and controlled the eastern Mediterranean, so Asian goods reached Western Europe only through Ottoman and Venetian middlemen at high prices.
Portugal was already searching for a sea route around Africa.
In January 1492 the Spanish monarchs Ferdinand and Isabella completed the Reconquista by taking Granada, the last Muslim state in Iberia, which freed money, soldiers and crusading zeal for new ventures.
A generation later the Protestant Reformation, begun by Martin Luther in 1517, split Western Christianity and turned religious rivalry into another reason to compete overseas.
West Africa. West Africa held powerful states (the Songhay Empire on the Niger, the kingdoms of Benin and Kongo nearer the coast) linked to the Mediterranean by trans-Saharan trade in gold, salt and enslaved people.
From the 1440s Portuguese ships traded along the Atlantic coast for gold and captives, and in 1482 they built the fort of São Jorge da Mina (Elmina) on the Gold Coast.
Slavery existed in many West African societies, usually as the capture of war prisoners and their use as laborers or dependents; the Atlantic trade would turn it into something much larger.
Context, in the exam, is exactly this kind of material: a specific development before or around a topic that explains why the topic happened the way it did.
Here is the pattern you can reuse: "Before 1492, [specific development] meant that [the topic] happened because ..."
How historians know about Native societies before contact
There are no written records from North America before contact (the Maya and Aztec wrote, far to the south), so historians rely on archaeology, oral traditions handed down in Native nations, studies of languages and climate, and the earliest European descriptions.
Each kind of evidence has limits.
European accounts are primary sources (made at the time by participants or observers), but their writers often misunderstood what they saw.
A modern historian's book is a secondary source: a later account that interprets primary evidence.
You will meet both kinds on the exam, and Short-answer Question 1 is always built on two secondary sources.
Dated timeline: Native North America before contact
Date
Development
At least 15,000 years ago
People living in the Americas, having arrived from Asia
About 9,000 years ago
Maize domesticated from a wild grass (teosinte) in southern Mexico
About 4,000 years ago
Maize grown in the present-day American Southwest
About 450 to 1450 CE
Hohokam irrigation canals in the Salt and Gila river valleys (present-day Arizona)
About 850 to 1150
Ancestral Puebloan great houses at Chaco Canyon (present-day New Mexico)
About 1050 to 1200
Cahokia, near present-day St. Louis, at its height
1190s to about 1300
Mesa Verde cliff dwellings built, then left during the great drought of the late 1200s
By 1491
Pueblo towns such as Acoma, Zuni and Hopi; the Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) Confederacy formed (date debated); Mississippian chiefdoms in the Southeast
1541
Coronado's expedition meets mobile bison hunters on the southern Plains
1585
English artist John White paints Algonquian villages near Roanoke
Maize and the Southwest
"The spread of maize cultivation from present-day Mexico northward into the present-day American Southwest and beyond supported economic development, settlement, advanced irrigation, and social diversification among societies."
Maize (corn) was the most important crop in the Americas.
Farmers in southern Mexico bred it from teosinte, a wild grass with tiny cobs, about 9,000 years ago.
Over thousands of years, larger-eared varieties were traded and carried northward, and by about 4,000 years ago people in the present-day Southwest were planting it.
Maize changed what was possible.
A field of corn yields far more food per acre than gathering wild seeds, and dried corn stores for months, so a farming community could stay in one place all year, feed more people and support people who did not farm.
That is what the four effects in the statement mean:
- Economic development: food surpluses could be stored and traded. Southwestern towns traded turquoise and cotton cloth southward for copper bells and the bright feathers of macaws, birds that live in Mexico.
- Settlement: farmers built permanent towns. The Ancestral Puebloans (older books call them the Anasazi) raised multistory "great houses" with hundreds of rooms at Chaco Canyon between about 850 and 1150, and later built cliff dwellings at Mesa Verde. By 1491 their descendants, the Pueblo peoples, lived in multistory adobe and stone towns such as Acoma, which sits on a high mesa and has been lived in since about the twelfth century.
- Advanced irrigation: in a desert, maize needs water. The Hohokam of present-day Arizona dug hundreds of miles of canals from the Salt and Gila rivers between about 450 and 1450 CE, one of the largest irrigation systems in the precontact Americas. Pueblo farmers used check dams, terraces and ditches to catch rain and floodwater.
- Social diversification: when not everyone has to find food, societies develop different roles. Pueblo towns had religious leaders and societies who led ceremonies in round underground chambers called kivas, clans that organized land and marriage, and craft specialists in pottery and weaving.
"And beyond" matters too.
Maize spread east into the Mississippi Valley and the Eastern Woodlands, especially after about 800 CE, where it supported the large towns you meet below.
Notice the reasoning.
The environment did not simply decide how people lived: people transformed it, by breeding a new crop and digging canals.
But the environment also set limits.
The great drought of the late 1200s helped push Ancestral Puebloans to leave the Four Corners region and move to the Rio Grande valley and other places with more reliable water.
Explaining "how and why" Native peoples interacted with the environment means showing both directions: adaptation to the land and transformation of it.
The Great Basin and the western Great Plains
"Societies responded to the aridity of the Great Basin and the grasslands of the western Great Plains by developing largely mobile lifestyles."
The Great Basin (most of present-day Nevada and Utah and parts of the states around them) gets so little rain that farming was rarely possible.
Peoples such as the Shoshone, Paiute and Ute lived in small family bands that moved through a yearly cycle, or seasonal round: pine nuts (piñon) in the mountains in the fall, seeds and roots in spring and summer, rabbits caught in communal drives with nets, and fish from lakes where they existed.
Their shelters were light brush houses they could leave behind.
Small, mobile bands were not a sign of a "simple" society; they were a skilled response to a land where staying in one place meant starving.
The western Great Plains were grassland, too dry for farming away from the river valleys, but home to huge herds of bison.
Plains peoples hunted bison on foot, sometimes driving herds over cliffs or into corrals, and used every part of the animal for food, clothing, tents, tools and fuel.
Before 1492 there were no horses in the Americas (they had died out thousands of years earlier), so people moved camp with dogs pulling a travois, a frame of two poles dragged behind the animal.
The Spanish commander Francisco Vázquez de Coronado met bison hunters on the southern Plains in 1541 and described people who lived in hide tents and moved with the herds, using dogs to carry their belongings; most historians identify these people, whom the Spanish called Querechos, as ancestors of the Plains Apache.
The drawing below shows what a camp of these walking bison hunters looked like.
Look for what is missing: there is not a single horse.
Modern drawing in old-engraving style, made for these notes: a camp of southern Plains bison hunters in the 1500s, moving with dogs and travois.
Two cautions.
First, the statement says "western" Great Plains.
Along the rivers of the eastern Plains, peoples such as the Wichita, Pawnee and Mandan farmed maize, beans and squash in permanent villages and hunted bison seasonally.
Second, the horse-riding Plains life of the Lakota or Comanche that many people picture belongs to the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries: horses spread onto the Plains from Spanish New Mexico mainly after the Pueblo Revolt of 1680.
Using mounted bison hunting as evidence for 1491 to 1607 is a chronology error.
The Northeast, the Mississippi Valley and the Atlantic seaboard
"In the Northeast, the Mississippi River Valley, and along the Atlantic seaboard, some societies developed mixed agricultural and hunter-gatherer economies that favored the development of permanent villages."
A mixed economy combined farming with hunting, fishing and gathering.
Across the Eastern Woodlands, women usually farmed the "Three Sisters" (maize, beans and squash planted together: the beans climb the corn stalks and add nitrogen to the soil, and the squash leaves shade out weeds), while men hunted deer, fished and cleared fields.
Because crops anchored people to their fields for much of the year, and wild foods filled the gaps, these societies lived in permanent villages, though some moved their villages every decade or two when the soil and firewood near them ran out.
- The Northeast. Iroquoian-speaking peoples lived in palisaded villages of longhouses, long bark-covered buildings shared by several related families. The Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) were matrilineal: families traced descent through the mother, women controlled the fields and the houses, and clan mothers chose the men who served as chiefs. Five nations (the Mohawk, Oneida, Onondaga, Cayuga and Seneca) joined in the Haudenosaunee Confederacy, bound by the Great Law of Peace, before Europeans arrived; historians and Haudenosaunee tradition date its founding anywhere from the twelfth century to about 1500. The Confederacy did not end war: the Haudenosaunee and their Huron (Wendat) neighbors were rivals.
- The Mississippi River Valley. Maize farming supported the Mississippian culture from about 800 CE. Its greatest city, Cahokia, near present-day St. Louis, held perhaps 10,000 to 20,000 people at its height around 1050 to 1200, with plazas and more than a hundred earthen mounds; Monks Mound is the largest earthwork in North America. Cahokia was largely abandoned by about 1350, but Mississippian chiefdoms with mound towns, ruled by hereditary chiefs, still existed in the Southeast when the Spanish explorer Hernando de Soto marched through in 1539 to 1542.
- The Atlantic seaboard. Algonquian-speaking peoples lived along the coast from present-day New England to North Carolina. In the Chesapeake, the paramount chief Wahunsenaca (called Powhatan by the English) ruled roughly 30 tribes in a chiefdom the English met in 1607. Farther south, near Roanoke, the English artist John White painted Secotan and Pomeiooc villages in 1585, showing mat-covered houses, maize fields at different stages of growth, fish weirs and dances; engravings of his paintings were printed in Europe in 1590.
Eastern peoples also reshaped their environment.
They set controlled fires to clear underbrush, which made forests more open, improved hunting and opened land for fields.
Europeans who later described "untouched wilderness" were looking at land that had been managed for centuries.
Check questions 1 and 2 use a drawing that stands for one of those European engravings of the 1590s.
The Northwest and California
"Societies in the Northwest and present-day California supported themselves by hunting and gathering, and in some areas developed settled communities supported by the vast resources of the ocean."
This statement corrects an easy assumption: that only farmers could build large, settled communities.
On the Northwest coast (present-day Washington, Oregon, British Columbia and southeast Alaska), rivers filled every year with salmon, and the sea held shellfish, seals and whales.
Peoples such as the Chinook, the Tlingit and the Makah caught and dried salmon in such quantities that they could live in large permanent villages of cedar plank houses without farming at all.
Wealth allowed sharp ranking: chiefly families, commoners and enslaved captives taken in raids.
Chiefs held potlatches, great feasts at which they gave away goods to show their status and claim rights.
The Chinook, at the mouth of the Columbia River, were traders whose market drew peoples from far inland.
The drawing below shows how a fishing people could live in a large, permanent village with no fields at all: the houses, the canoes and the drying racks all come from the forest and the sea.
Modern drawing in old-engraving style, made for these notes: a permanent plank-house village on the Northwest coast, fed by salmon.
In present-day California, peoples gathered acorns (which they ground and soaked to remove bitter tannins), seeds and roots, hunted and fished.
California's population before contact is often estimated at about 300,000, one of the densest in North America north of Mexico, without farming.
On the coast near present-day Santa Barbara, the Chumash built plank canoes called tomols to fish and to trade with the Channel Islands.
Putting it together: comparison and causation
The learning objective asks "how and why" Native peoples interacted with the environment, which is a causation question, and the period also invites comparison.
Two sentences you can reuse:
- Comparison: "Like the Pueblo peoples of the Southwest, the Haudenosaunee of the Northeast farmed maize and lived in permanent villages; unlike the Pueblos, they combined farming with extensive hunting and did not need irrigation, because the Northeast had enough rain."
- Causation: "The main reason that Great Basin peoples lived in small mobile bands was the region's aridity, which made farming impossible; the main reason that Northwest coast peoples could live in large permanent villages without farming was the abundance of salmon and other ocean resources."
The map below sorts the regions by the kind of economy the statements describe.
It is an approximate sketch of broad patterns: boundaries between ways of life were never sharp lines, many peoples combined strategies, and the far north (where farming was rarely possible) is left blank.
The triangles mark three earlier sites you have met in this section, all left before 1491; the dot marks Acoma, a Pueblo town lived in by 1491.
Read it as the exam would: farming societies cluster where there was enough water (the rainy East) or where people brought water to the fields (the irrigated Southwest); mobile societies sit in the dry interior; settled non-farming societies sit along the Pacific coast, where the ocean supplied what farms supplied elsewhere.
Used again in: the diversity of Native societies shapes how they met Spanish, French and English colonizers (1.6 and Unit 2), the Pueblo Revolt of 1680 and the spread of horses onto the Plains (Unit 2), and Native resistance and removal (Units 3, 4 and 6).
- Maize: corn, a crop domesticated in southern Mexico about 9,000 years ago and the staple food of most farming societies in the Americas.
- Three Sisters: maize, beans and squash planted together, the core of Eastern Woodlands and many Southwestern farming systems.
- Mixed economy: an economy that combines farming with hunting, fishing and gathering.
- Matrilineal: tracing descent and inheritance through the mother's line, as the Haudenosaunee and many other Native societies did.
- Chiefdom: a society ruled by hereditary chiefs over several villages, such as the Mississippian mound towns or Powhatan's Chesapeake chiefdom.
- Primary and secondary sources: a primary source was made at the time by a participant or observer; a secondary source is a later account that interprets the past.
B. Briefly explain one way that the spread of maize cultivation affected societies in the present-day American Southwest in the period before 1492.
Full-credit response: Maize farming let the Hohokam of present-day Arizona settle in permanent towns in the Salt and Gila river valleys, where between about 450 and 1450 CE they dug hundreds of miles of irrigation canals to water their corn.
Because a reliable harvest could be stored, they no longer had to move with the seasons, and the work of building and sharing canals required organization and leadership.
- Point 1 (Part B): a specific society (the Hohokam), a specific effect (permanent settlement with large-scale irrigation), and the link (stored harvests made staying put possible; canals needed organization). Accept: the Ancestral Puebloans building multistory great houses at Chaco Canyon (about 850 to 1150) supported by maize surpluses; Pueblo towns such as Acoma developing religious leaders and craft specialists once farming freed some people from food-getting; trade in turquoise for macaw feathers from Mexico made possible by surpluses. Does not earn: "maize helped them grow food" (no specific society or effect); the arrival of horses (after 1492 and not a maize effect); the Columbian Exchange carrying maize to Europe (wrong direction and outside the window).
Weaker response: "Maize was very important to Native Americans because it was their main crop and they ate it a lot."
This earns nothing: it names a fact but describes no specific society and no effect, and it never explains how maize changed anything.
Source 1 and Source 2 below are written for this practice in the exam's form.
Read each whole, then say each historian's main claim to yourself in one sentence before you look at the parts.
Source 1
"Before Europeans arrived, the land itself set the terms of Native life.
Where rain fell reliably, as in the eastern woodlands, people could farm and build villages; where it did not, as in the deserts between the Rocky Mountains and the Sierra Nevada, families had to keep moving to survive.
The salmon rivers of the Pacific coast allowed villages without fields.
Across the continent, the great variety of Native ways of life is best understood as a set of skilled adjustments to very different climates, soils and food supplies."
Source: A historian, in a history of North America before 1600 published in 2015 (written for this practice)
Source 2
"Native peoples did not merely fit themselves to the land; they remade it.
Farmers bred new crops and carried them hundreds of miles, engineers moved river water into desert fields, and hunters used fire to turn forests into open parkland.
Just as important were the political choices people made.
Leaders made alliances, organized long-distance trade and waged war.
The North America that Europeans entered was a human landscape shaped by centuries of decisions, and those decisions explain its diversity as much as climate does."
Source: A historian, in a study of Native American political history published in 2019 (written for this practice)
Respond to parts A, B, and C.
A. Briefly describe one major difference between the two historians' interpretations of Native American societies before European contact.
B. Briefly explain how one event or development from 900 to 1600 not directly mentioned in the excerpts could be used to support the argument in Source 1.
C. Briefly explain how one event or development from 900 to 1600 not directly mentioned in the excerpts could be used to support the argument in Source 2.
Response:
A. Source 1 argues that Native societies were shaped mainly by their environments, so their diversity reflects adjustments to climate and food supply, while Source 2 argues that Native peoples actively changed their environments and made political decisions, so human choices explain their diversity as much as climate.
B. The western Great Plains supports Source 1. Because the grasslands were too dry for farming away from the rivers, peoples such as the ancestors of the Plains Apache lived by following the bison herds on foot, moving their hide tents with dogs pulling travois, as Coronado's expedition saw in 1541. Their mobile life was an adjustment to the land's food supply, which is what Source 1 argues.
C. The rise of Cahokia supports Source 2. Between about 1050 and 1200, people near present-day St. Louis built a city of perhaps 10,000 to 20,000 with more than a hundred earthen mounds, organized by leaders who controlled labor and trade along the Mississippi. A city of this size was a human and political creation, not just a response to climate, which supports Source 2's claim that decisions shaped Native North America.
- Point 1 (Part A): two claims, one per historian, in one sentence: environment as the main cause against human choices and transformation. Accept: Source 1 treats Native peoples as adapting to nature, while Source 2 treats them as reshaping nature and building political institutions; Source 1 stresses limits set by climate, Source 2 stresses human agency. Does not earn: "Source 1 is about climate and Source 2 is about politics" (topics, not claims); "both say Native societies were diverse" (a similarity); quoting a sentence from each excerpt with no description.
- Point 2 (Part B): a development in the window, not in Source 1, with the link to environmental adjustment. Accept: Ancestral Puebloans leaving Mesa Verde and the Four Corners during the great drought of the late 1200s, showing climate driving where people could live; California peoples relying on acorns, an abundant local food, with no need to farm. Does not earn: salmon villages of the Northwest coast or the mobile families of the Great Basin deserts (both already in the excerpt); Plains peoples riding horses (horses spread onto the Plains after 1680, outside the window); "Native Americans adapted to their environment" (no specific development).
- Point 3 (Part C): a development in the window, not in Source 2, with the link to human choice. Accept: the formation of the Haudenosaunee Confederacy under the Great Law of Peace, a political decision that joined five nations; Powhatan's chiefdom uniting about 30 Chesapeake tribes by 1607; the Mississippian chiefdoms of the Southeast, whose hereditary chiefs ruled mound towns that de Soto's expedition met in 1539 to 1542. Does not earn: Haudenosaunee women farming the Three Sisters with no link to choice or transformation (it fits the topic but not the historian); the arrival of Europeans (not a Native decision); controlled burning of forests or desert irrigation canals (both already in the excerpt).
Weaker response, and what it loses: A: "Source 1 talks about the environment and Source 2 talks about people."
(topics, not claims: 0).
B: "The Plains Indians hunted buffalo on horses."
(outside the window: 0).
C: "Native Americans had trade."
(no specific development, no link: 0).
Total 0 of 3, though every sentence is about the right topic.
Total [3]
Prompt: Evaluate the extent to which the natural environment shaped the economies and settlement patterns of Native American societies in North America from 1491 to 1607.
Context paragraph: Over at least 15,000 years, Native peoples spread across North America and developed hundreds of societies.
The most important development behind the differences among them was the spread of maize from southern Mexico, where it was domesticated about 9,000 years ago, northward into the Southwest by about 4,000 years ago and into the Mississippi Valley and Eastern Woodlands after about 800 CE.
Where maize could grow, it allowed people to store food and settle; where it could not, they relied on wild foods.
[Row B, contextualization, 1 point: a specific, dated development before the window, tied to the prompt's topic of economies and settlement.]
Thesis: From 1491 to 1607 the natural environment shaped Native economies and settlement to a large extent, because rainfall and food supply decided whether people could farm, move with the seasons or fish from settled villages; however, the environment did not decide everything, since Native peoples also transformed their land through irrigation and fire and built political systems that rainfall alone cannot explain.
[Row A, thesis, 1 point: a defensible claim with a line of reasoning (rainfall and food supply), categories (farm, move, fish), and a qualification.]
Body paragraph: The environment's strongest effect appears in the contrast between the dry interior and the wetter regions.
In the Great Basin, low rainfall made farming nearly impossible, so the Shoshone and Paiute lived in small bands that moved through a seasonal round of pine nuts, seeds and rabbit drives.
On the western Great Plains, grassland too dry for fields supported bison, and the people Coronado met in 1541 followed the herds on foot, carrying their hide tents with dogs.
By contrast, the Haudenosaunee of the rainy Northeast farmed maize, beans and squash and lived in palisaded longhouse villages for years at a time.
Each case shows the environment setting the basic choice between moving and settling.
Yet the Hohokam of the Arizona desert, who irrigated their maize with hundreds of miles of canals, show that people could overcome a dry environment when they organized to do so.
[Row C, evidence: four specific, dated examples used to support the argument, which earns 2 points across the essay.
Row D, reasoning: causation frames the paragraph (environment as cause) and the last sentence begins the complexity route by qualifying it with counter-evidence.]
What a weaker version scores: A thesis that says "The environment shaped Native American societies a lot" restates the prompt and earns no thesis point; a context sentence that says "Native Americans lived in America for a long time" is a passing phrase and earns nothing.
When a question is about Native societies, make Native peoples the actors and name them: the Hohokam, the Pueblo peoples, the Haudenosaunee, the Shoshone.
Strong answers show societies that were many, varied and changing, with their own conflicts and alliances; answers that treat "Native Americans" as one peaceful group lose accuracy, and the Aztec and Inca belong to Mexico and the Andes, not to an answer about North America north of Mexico.
- Plains peoples on horseback before 1607. Fix: there were no horses in the Americas before the Spanish brought them; Plains peoples hunted on foot with dogs until horses spread north mainly after 1680. Why tempting: the mounted Plains warrior is the most familiar image of Native America, but it belongs to the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries.
- "All Native Americans were nomadic hunters" or "all were farmers." Fix: the KCs describe four different patterns, from irrigated farming towns to mobile bands to non-farming fishing villages; use "many" and "some". Why tempting: textbooks often summarize with one picture.
- Treating the environment as the only cause. Fix: show adaptation and transformation together (canals, fire, crop breeding) and political choices (the Haudenosaunee Confederacy). Why tempting: the statement on the Great Basin and the Plains uses the word "responded", but the other statements describe people changing their land.
- Using the Aztec or Inca for a North American prompt. Fix: they are evidence for Spanish conquest in 1.4, but a question about societies in North America wants peoples in present-day United States and Canada. Why tempting: they are the best-known precontact empires.
- Saying settled villages needed farming. Fix: Northwest coast peoples lived in large permanent villages supported by salmon and the sea. Why tempting: in the East and Southwest, settlement and farming went together.
Check your understanding
1. Questions 1 and 2 refer to the following image.
The drawing below stands for a European engraving of about 1590.
Source: Modern drawing in old-engraving style of an Algonquian village on the coast of present-day North Carolina, standing for an engraving published in Europe in 1590 (drawn for this practice)
The image most directly illustrates which of the following developments?
- (A) Societies in the Great Basin responding to aridity by developing largely mobile lifestyles
- (B) Societies along the Atlantic seaboard developing mixed agricultural and hunter-gatherer economies that favored permanent villages
- (C) Societies on the Northwest coast building settled communities supported mainly by ocean resources
- (D) Spanish colonists introducing European crops and livestock to Native farmers
Total [1]
2. Which of the following developments most directly made possible the farming shown in the image?
- (A) The arrival of European crops through the Columbian Exchange after 1492
- (B) The construction of irrigation canals from the Salt and Gila rivers
- (C) The spread of maize cultivation northward from present-day Mexico over many centuries
- (D) The introduction of the horse, which allowed farmers to plow larger fields
Total [1]
3. Questions 3 and 4 refer to the following excerpt.
"And after seventeen days' march I came to a settlement of Indians who are called Querechos, who travel around with these cows, who do not plant, and who eat the raw flesh and drink the blood of the cows they kill, and they tan the skins of the cows, with which all the people of this country dress themselves here.
They have little field tents made of the hides of the cows, tanned and greased, very well made, in which they live while they travel around near the cows, moving with these.
They have dogs which they load, which carry their tents and poles and belongings."
Source: Francisco Vázquez de Coronado, Spanish commander, letter to King Charles I of Spain, from the province of Tiguex (present-day New Mexico), October 20, 1541; translated by George Parker Winship, 1904
cows: the Spanish name for bison
The way of life described in the excerpt is best understood as
- (A) a response to the grasslands of the western Great Plains, where farming was difficult away from the rivers
- (B) a result of Spanish settlement, which pushed Native farmers off their lands onto the Plains
- (C) a form of the mixed agricultural economy found in the Mississippi River Valley
- (D) an adaptation made possible by horses that the Spanish had brought to the Plains
Total [1]
4. Which of the following later developments most changed the way of life described in the excerpt?
- (A) The founding of the English colony at Jamestown in 1607
- (B) The adoption of the Three Sisters crops by Plains peoples in the 1700s
- (C) The arrival of the Second Great Awakening in the western territories in the early 1800s
- (D) The spread of horses onto the Plains from Spanish New Mexico, especially after 1680
Total [1]
5. Briefly describe one way that societies on the western Great Plains obtained food or moved their camps in the period 1491 to 1607.
Total [1]
6. Refer to the map of Native American economies about 1491 shown earlier in this section.
Source: Approximate sketch map of economic patterns among Native American societies about 1491, based on the work of archaeologists and historians (drawn for this practice)
Respond to parts A, B, and C.
A. Briefly describe one pattern in the location of Native American economies shown on the map.
B. Briefly explain how one development before 1491 contributed to the pattern shown on the map.
C. Briefly explain how one development from 1607 to 1754 changed the ways of life of one group of Native Americans in a region shown on the map.
Total [3]
7. Write the thesis and a contextualization paragraph for this long essay prompt.
Evaluate the extent to which Native American societies in different regions of North America differed from one another from 1491 to 1607.
Total [2]
Answers
1. (B). The mat-covered houses in a permanent village, the maize fields and the fishing and deer hunting together show a mixed agricultural and hunter-gatherer economy on the Atlantic seaboard. (A) is tempting because the men are hunting, but the fields and lasting houses rule out a mobile life. (C) is wrong because the village farms and the setting is the Atlantic coast, not the Pacific. (D) is wrong in place and time: the crops shown (maize, beans, squash) are American, and the region had no Spanish colonists.
2. (C). Maize had been carried and bred northward from southern Mexico over thousands of years, reaching the Southwest about 4,000 years ago and the East after about 800 CE. (A) reverses the direction: maize went from the Americas to Europe. (B) is real but belongs to the Hohokam of the Arizona desert; the rainy Atlantic coast did not need canals. (D) is wrong twice: there were no horses in the region, and Native farmers used hoes, not plows.
3. (A). The Querechos did "not plant" and lived by following the bison in hide tents, an adaptation to grassland too dry for farming. (B) is tempting because Spanish expansion did later push peoples around, but in 1541 the Spanish had only just arrived. (C) is wrong because these people did not farm. (D) is the classic chronology trap: Coronado describes dogs carrying the tents, because Plains peoples did not yet have horses.
4. (D). Horses, spreading north from Spanish New Mexico mainly after the Pueblo Revolt of 1680, let Plains peoples hunt bison faster and move farther, and drew new nations such as the Lakota and Comanche onto the Plains. (A) is real but far to the east and had no effect on the southern Plains. (C) is real but had little effect on Plains bison hunting. (B) did not happen; mounted Plains peoples became more mobile, not more agricultural.
5. Peoples of the western Great Plains, such as the ancestors of the Plains Apache, hunted bison on foot, sometimes driving herds over cliffs or into corrals, and used the meat, hides and bones for food, tents and tools, moving camp with dogs that pulled travois.
- Point 1: a specific way of getting food or moving, described with at least one characteristic. Accept: following the bison herds through the year and living in portable hide tents; drying bison meat in thin strips to store it. Does not earn: hunting buffalo on horseback (horses spread onto the Plains mainly after 1680, so this is outside the 1491 to 1607 window); "they hunted" (a bare term with no characteristic); farming maize in irrigated fields (describes the Southwest).
6. Full answer, one point per part.
- Point 1 (Part A): Farming societies were concentrated in the Southwest and in the East from the Mississippi Valley to the Atlantic seaboard, while largely mobile societies occupied the dry Great Basin and western Great Plains between them. Accept: settled non-farming societies lined the Pacific coast, from the Northwest to California; farming appeared where rainfall was reliable or where water could be brought to fields. Does not earn: "different regions had different economies" (no pattern or location); a pattern not shown on the map.
- Point 2 (Part B): The spread of maize cultivation from southern Mexico, where it was domesticated about 9,000 years ago, into the Southwest by about 4,000 years ago and into the Mississippi Valley and the East after about 800 CE gave societies in those regions a storable crop, which explains why farming societies sit in the Southwest and the East. Accept: the Hohokam canals (about 450 to 1450 CE) making desert farming possible in the Southwest; the rise of Mississippian chiefdoms such as Cahokia around 1050 to 1200 on maize farming. Does not earn: the Columbian Exchange (after 1491); "the climate" with no development.
- Point 3 (Part C): After the Pueblo Revolt of 1680, horses from Spanish New Mexico spread onto the Great Plains, and nations such as the Comanche and Lakota became mounted bison hunters who could travel farther, hunt more efficiently and dominate trade and war on the Plains. Accept: Haudenosaunee nations in the Northeast fighting the Beaver Wars (from the 1640s) to control the fur trade with Europeans; Pueblo peoples of the Southwest forced into Spanish missions and labor, leading to the Pueblo Revolt of 1680; Algonquian peoples of the Chesapeake losing land to tobacco planters after the wars of 1622 and 1644. Does not earn: the Dawes Act (1887, outside the window); Indian Removal under Andrew Jackson (1830s, outside the window); "Native Americans were affected by Europeans" (no specific group or change).
7. A strong answer, credited row by row.
- Thesis (Row A): "From 1491 to 1607 Native American societies differed greatly from one another in their economies and settlement, because each region's rainfall and food supply shaped whether people farmed, moved or fished, but they also shared features such as long-distance trade, kinship-based politics and religions rooted in the natural world." This earns: a defensible claim, a line of reasoning (rainfall and food supply), categories, and a similarity that sets up complexity.
- Contextualization (Row B): "Native peoples had lived in North America for at least 15,000 years and had spread into every environment, from the deserts of the Southwest to the forests of the Northeast and the Pacific coast. The spread of maize from southern Mexico, reaching the Southwest about 4,000 years ago and the East after about 800 CE, divided the continent into regions where farming was possible and regions where it was not." This earns: a specific, dated development before the window that explains why differences existed.
- Does not earn: a thesis that only says "Native societies were very different" (restates the prompt); context that says "Columbus arrived in 1492" with no link to differences among Native societies.